Work

Understanding decision-making regarding prenatal diagnostic testing for down syndrome and termination of pregnancy: an interpretive phenomenological study

Year: 2018
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Pregnant women or couples who screen high risk for a baby with Down syndrome (DS) are faced with having to make life changing decisions.Firstly, they need to decide whether they want prenatal diagnostic testing to confirm whether the baby has DS or not.If this diagnosis is confirmed, they have the added burden of deciding between a termination of pregnancy (TOP) and giving birth to a baby with DS.The pregnant women and couples often need to make these decisions while feeling emotionally distressed and overloaded by information.This may cause them to make decisions they regret, which may have a long-term negative impact on their psychological well-being and daily lives.Therefore, the current study aimed at gaining a deeper understanding of how women/couples experience their decision-making process around the option of prenatal diagnosis (PND) for DS and TOP, in order to improve their satisfaction with the decisions they make.This study particularly focused on the experiences of women/couples who attend the prenatal clinic at a public sector hospital, Tygerberg Hospital, in Cape Town, South Africa (SA).The study was conducted using a qualitative interpretive phenomenological approach.A total of 27 women and six couples were recruited using purposive sampling.These participants were selected and grouped according to the decisions they made, in order to investigate the decision-making process and impact of each decision.The four groups were: those participants who declined PND, who accepted PND, who declined TOP and who accepted TOP.In-depth interviews were conducted to collect the data.These interviews were conducted at different intervals during and after the outcome of the pregnancy.The interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed.Thematic analysis was used to derive meaning from the data.The findings of the study highlights the complexity of the decision-making processes regarding PND for DS and TOP.The women/couples reported several factors influencing their decisionmaking processes including their perceived severity of DS, interpersonal relationships, procedure related risks, risk perception, perceived benefit of procedure, family structure, religious values and moral beliefs.It was noted that those women/couples who made decisions which were not in line with their religious beliefs and moral values experienced the most ambivalence and feelings of regret.Each decision was found to have a major impact on the women's/couples' psychological wellbeing, interpersonal relationships and daily lives.Therefore, this study also illustrated the additional support these women/couples require, in order to cope with the anxiety caused by their high risk status of DS and their decisions regarding PND and TOP.
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2799321070
Cites: 203
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10