Work

Key Ideas In Proof In Undergraduate Mathematics Classrooms

Year: 2017
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The mathematics education literature reveals an ongoing interest in fostering the ability of students to construct and reconstruct proofs. One promising tool to this end is the concept of “key idea”. Observing groups of undergraduate mathematics students, the study examined in some detail how such students understand the concept of key idea and how well they identify the key ideas in a proof and use them in reconstructing it. The study used a mixed methods design, driven primarily by qualitative methods, while incorporating a complementary quantitative component. Participants in the study were first-year and mixed-year (2nd to 4th) university mathematics students. Data were collected from four sources: (1) an online survey, (2) classroom observations in the form of audio recordings and field notes, (3) semi-structured interviews with students, and (4) students’ work on identifying key ideas in proofs and reconstructing a proof. The study results form a detailed portrayal of students’ perceptions of key ideas as well as the ways they go about identifying and using key ideas in reconstructing a proof. The picture is complex. While most of the students reported that they consciously identified key ideas in proofs they were studying, they varied widely in their understanding of the concept itself. Key ideas were perceived by the students as “important points”, as “blueprints”, as “landmarks and pathways” or as “steps to follow”. When asked to identify key ideas in specific proofs, most of the students were unable to articulate clear responses. Very few students were able to use precise language and point to an idea that helped them both understand the proof and reconstruct it. These findings are a significant addition to our present knowledge of undergraduate mathematics students’ ability to see the important ideas embedded in proofs. They imply that mathematics educators, in their desire to see students enhance their understanding of proof and proving by the use of key ideas, will need to extend considerable support to students by actively intervening to draw their attention to features of proofs that are candidates for key ideas.
Author: Xiaoheng Yan
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2799992737
Cites: 132
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10