A meta-analysis of selected advance organizer research reports from 1960-1977 /
Year: 1978
Type: review
Abstract: M ajor Field: not given any introductory materials.Other studies showed no significant differences between experimental and control groups.In an attempt to identify variables which might help to explain these apparent inconsistencies, Barnes and Clawson classified the studies according to length of treat ment, learning ability of subjects, grade level, mode of presentation of the advance organizer, subject area, and cognitive level of the test questions.However, they did not form any generalizations (Barnes and Clawson, 1975, p. 551).The type of review done by Barnes and Clawson has two main limitations.One limitation is that they did not per form any statistical analysis of their data.Because of the large number of variables involved, simple frequency counts probably will not provide a sufficient basis for the forma tion of valid generalizations.Some statistical analysis, including multivariate procedures, should be used to reveal relationships and to help identify variables that may p r o vide insight in developing explanations of the reported results.A second limitation of their review is that they did not consider the content and organizational properties of the materials used as advance organizers.Since there is not complete agreement as to the specific definition of the term advance organizer, this m a y be a very important var i able.Many researchers have indicated that they feel that Ausubel's definition of advance organizer is too vague to provide specific guidelines for the construction of m a t e rials to serve as advance organizers (Allen, 1970a, p. 62; Lucas, 1972, p. 65; Saretsky, 1975, p. 92; Toth, 1975, p. 3).Consequently, there is considerable variety in the variables (Baylis, 1975; Lawton, 1977).In both studies, changes were noted as a result of exposure to the advance organizer.
Author: M. James Kozlow
Institution: The Ohio State University
Language: English
Subfield: Experimental and Cognitive Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2801951295
