Year: 2018
Type: book-review
Abstract: It speaks to the importance of Michel Foucault's work for contemporary criminology that Mariana Valverde's Michel Foucault was the first book to be released in Routledge's new series 'Key Thinkers in Criminology'.The reception of Foucault's thought has, in her account, enabled critical criminology to surpass the limitations of its Marxist heritage by shifting attention from ideological functions to problematizations, that is, to the practices of rendering some phenomenon as a problem for theory or society (8-10).His attention to practices follows Nietzsche's insight that philosophy and theory present "ex post facto rationalizations" of existing social practices (18), which serves as a critique of a functionalist fallacy at work in, for example, the discourse of ideological functions.The functionalist fallacy posits that the reason of existence of a certain phenomenon is the function it fulfills in a given social order.Against this, the genealogical approach of Foucault and Nietzsche aims to show that practices can travel between contexts, rise to dominance, be forgotten, and then suddenly be retrieved from times past, all the while taking on new functions and meanings (18-21).Breaking with the triad of "acts, persons or institutions" (16), this attention to practices and problematizations significantly expands criminology's field of study because the practices it investigates may be found in, but are not restricted to, the fields of criminal justice and crime control (11-14).Therefore, Valverde sees her book less as an introduction to Foucault as a criminological thinkerand she criticizes such readings throughout -but rather as a critique of criminology whose "most significant legacy" is his unique style of thought (8).Most chapters of Michel Foucault deal in detail with specific works of his, namely Discipline and Punish (chapter 2), volume one of the History of Sexuality (chapter 3), the Collège de France lectures on Security, Territory, Population (chapter 4, followed by chapter 5 on Governmentality Studies) and on The Punitive Society (chapter 6), as well as the two shorter lecture series Truth and Juridical Forms and Wrongdoing and Truth-Telling (chapter 7).Throughout the book, Valverde seeks to correct common errors of reception.In her reading of Discipline and Punish, she argues that Foucault's simplified mode of presentation and his use of "illustrative vignettes", as well as the translator's choice to render the French "suveiller" not as "Surveil" but as "Discipline", have contributed simplistic and reified readings of his work that miss the essential relationality of power (35-36).While Foucault shows how penal sanctions, from the Ancien Régime to the French Revolution, became less corporeal and more incarcerating, he did not aim to provide an accurate historical description, but to describe the formation of a certain type of governing.
Source: Foucault Studies
Author: Christian Hammermann
Institution: Universität Hamburg
Language: English
Topic: Foucault, Power, and Ethics
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W2810975397
