Five: Reforming Educational Accountability
Year: 2002
Type: article
Abstract: This paper examines efforts since 1999 to address California's education crises through a system of accountability for schools and school-level personnel.Since 1999, California has budgeted $1.17 billion to reward teachers and schools whose students improve scores on a single standardized test.In the same period, on the basis of the same test, 1290 of the 8563 schools in the state have been placed in a program of "immediate intervention" for "underperforming schools."There have been many critics of the implementation of accountability in California.This paper looks beyond questions of implementation to what I will argue are some fundamental design flaws in the accountability system for K-12 education.I also sketch the design constraints to which a more adequate accountability system must conform if we are to achieve those goals now in the process of being delineated in a master plan for California public education.California public education at the K-12 level faces two related crises: a crisis quality and a crisis of equality.As a matter of statewide averages, in the past three decades California's public education system has by many measures fallen from among the best in the country to among the worst.For example, California is now 49 th among states in the ratio of teachers to students.2 Last year, the richest state in the country and the home of the Silicon Valley was ranked dead last among states in the availability of computers for instructional purposes.3 And the last time the federal government compared school facilities across the country, California trailed 48 states in the percentage of schools in inadequate condition.4 Plainly, the average quality of public schools in California is unacceptable.However grim, statewide averages mask a reality more troubling still.For individual children do not sit in average classrooms in average schools.Despite constitutionally mandated rough equality in per student funding for basic operations, California public schools remain radically unequal in what they deliver to children.In our worst schools, attended primarily by poor children and children of color, students may have little chance of being taught by an adequately trained teacher, be deprived of textbooks and other basic tools for learning, or be consigned to school facilities that can only be described as slums.5 The existence of these conditions is not seriously contested.Although Governor Davis is directing a massively 1 Professor of Law, UCLA School of Law.I am grateful to Valerie Grab, Laura Faer and Eric Lepping for their research assistance in preparing this paper.My thanks also to Harold Williams
Author: Gary Blasi
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W285721355
