Work

From Balkanisation to Boundary Crossing:Using a Teacher Learning Community to Explore the Impact of AssessmentOn Teaching and Learning in a Disadvantaged School

Year: 2009
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Irish education is currently witnessing a fundamental shift in focus from an emphasis\non curriculum revision, professional development and policy implementation to one of\nreview, with the concomitant effect that issues of evaluation and assessment are increasingly\nhigh on the agenda. This is evidenced by the publication in recent years of a series of\nevaluation reports which, in addition to identifying successes achieved, have highlighted a\nnumber of related iterative weaknesses in the system that continue to thwart progress. One is\nthe apparent lack of assessment literacy which has been attributed mainly, but not exclusively,\nto teachers. Another is the growing body of international evidence suggesting that\npedagogical practices in schools serving disadvantaged children are qualitatively different to\nthose found in more advantaged settings. Finally, there is the evidence that low levels of\nliteracy persist in Ireland, despite significant investment and innovation.\nIn responding to these challenges, this study examined the potential of a teacher\nlearning community (TLC) as a vehicle of professional development, to bring about changes\nin teachers’ understanding and use of Assessment for Learning (AfL), in order to improve the \nreading competency of a cohort of children attending a designated disadvantaged, junior\nschool, in the Republic of Ireland. Employing a partially mixed, concurrent, equal status,\nquantitative/qualitative design, the study investigated three research hypotheses pertaining to\n(1) children’s reading achievement, (2) their motivation to read/employment of AfL strategies\nwhen reading and (3) teachers’ knowledge, skills and attitudes of/to AfL. Outcomes from the\nquantitative data with respect to the first two hypotheses indicated that there were no\nstatistically significant differences in mean reading achievement between control and\nexperimental groups following the intervention, although significant differences were found\nfor reading strategies. The qualitative data relating to the third hypothesis revealed that\nimportant changes had occurred in teachers’ attitudes and classroom practice over the\nduration of the project. The study concludes by drawing attention to the potential of a TLC,\nreconceived as a boundary zone, to challenge the traditional balkanisation of teachers’\nworking lives.
Author: Zita Lysaght
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2886081804
Cites: 321
Cited by: 11
Related to: 9