Work

Discrimination in the Chinese Urban Labour Market

Year: 2018
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The household registration system (hukou) was established in the 1950s to record families' and individuals' residential information.All populations in China are divided into urban and rural hukou.With the transition of the Chinese economy from a planned economy to a market one, the hukou system has been reformed and its strict limitation relaxed.However, segregation between urban workers and rural-urban migrants in the Chinese labour market caused by the hukou system is an unresolved issue.Motivated by the current hukou situation in the Chinese labour market, this thesis empirically investigates wage discrimination, income aspirations and subjective well-being of urban workers and rural-urban migrants.Utilizing the China Health and Nutrition Survey (CHNS) from 1993 to 2011, wage differentials between urban workers and rural-urban migrants are explored in Chapter 2.Unlike previous Chinese research, which has regarded occupational distribution as an exogenous variable, occupation segregation is considered as an endogenous variable in the analysis.The Brown et al. (1980) decomposition method is utilized to decompose wage differentials, and the estimated results are divided into four parts: within-occupation explained and unexplained portions; and inter-occupational explained and unexplained portions.The purpose of Chapter 2 is to estimate the extent to which wage differentials can be attributed to within-occupation or inter-occupation portions and the extent to which wage differentials can be explained by different observed characteristics.The empirical findings show that the unexplained part is higher than that found using the Oaxaca & Ransom (1994) decomposition approach.The existence of wage differentials between urban workers and rural-urban migrants is mainly ascribed to inter-occupational wage differentials.In addition, among the total unexplained component, a large proportion is also due to an inter-occupation wage gap.In other words, rural-urban migrants do not have equal access to occupational choice.Chapter 3 investigates the relationship between hukou discrimination and income aspirations.Using data from the China General Social Survey (CGSS) 2010, this chapter compares the income aspirations of urban workers and rural-urban migrants and estimates the causal effect of hukou discrimination on income aspirations.Propensity XII score matching is utilized to match urban workers and rural-urban migrants, based on a range of similar human characteristics.The results from the propensity score matching analysis show that, although actual income aspirations of rural-urban migrants are lower than the counterfactual income aspirations, the difference between actual and counterfactual income aspirations is not significant.The reason for the insignificant effect of hukou status on income aspirations may be attributed to the fact that rural-urban migrants adapt to their disadvantaged status.In addition, it may be ascribed to unobserved occupational segregation.Motivated by the previous two chapters, Chapter 4 compares subjective well-being (SWB) between rural-urban migrants and urban workers, and also examines how the income aspirations shape their SWB.Using the same dataset as Chapter 3, rural-urban migrants report similar SWB to urban hukou workers.An ordered probit model is applied to explore the impact of income aspirations on subjective well-being.The results show that the income aspirations have no significant impact on SWB.The similar SWB between rural-urban migrants and urban residents cannot be explained by income aspirations, no matter which measurement of income aspirations is utilized in the analysis.In order to explain the similar happiness between rural migrants and urban residents, further analysis about the impact of socioeconomic status on SWB is conducted as well.The results show that, in Chinese context, it is social comparison rather than income aspiration that can help to explain why rural-urban migrants have similar levels of SWB.This thesis concludes that, although hukou limitations were relaxed gradually, individuals with different hukou status continue to experience different treatment in terms of income and occupation.However, this different treatment of rural-urban migrants does not have a significant effect on restricting migrants' aspirations.In addition, although rural-urban migrants are discriminated against, they report similar subjective well-being to their urban counterparts and similar perceptions of happiness.Thus, labour market policy should mainly promote an integrated labour market, which can provide equal access to occupational choice and wages.
Author: Dan Li
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2889727514
Cites: 152
Cited by:
Related to: 10