Work

Paternalism, Autonomy, and Food Regulation

Year: 2015
Type: article
Abstract: New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg recently proposed legislation that bans the sale of sugary drinks in containers larger than 16 ounces.1 The growth of the obesity epidemic suggests that proposals for similar measures will increase in coming years.As public health officials' focus shifts, campaigns against smoking are being replaced with campaigns against sugar, fat, and carbs.Governments may be quick to propose regulations that incapacitate our ability to make bad health choices. 2 Prima facie, it may seem that any inquiry into the justificatory grounding of Bloomberg's proposal or other 'food bans' would be nothing more than reengagement with familiar issues regarding paternalism, coercion, liberty, and respect for persons.Governments have a long history of approving legal mandates concerning smoking, narcotics, seatbelts, vaccinations and more.Philosophical discussions on the aforementioned have a prolific literature and Bloomberg's ban might seem like just an addition to the list.If so, we should simply reengage old arguments and apply them to the matter at hand.But this would be a mistake.Although state promotion of public health is an old phenomenon, Bloomberg's latest statute introduces new concerns.One way in which Bloomberg's ban is similar to past public health statutes is in its justificatory appeal to harm.Those who advocate legal restrictions on smoking, for instance, argue that such statutes prevent harm to both smokers and non-smokers.Along similar lines, seatbelt laws protect riders from injurious automobile accidents and mandated vaccinations prevent disease.The purported aim
Author: Maura Priest
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2892300006
FWCI:
Cites: 10
Cited by: 2
Related to: 9