Work

Reliving 24 Years in the next 12 Minutes: A Statistical and Personal History of University-Class Satellites

Year: 2018
Type: conference-paper
Abstract: In 2018, university-class satellites -- spacecraft built by university students for the express purpose of student training -- are widely accepted as a means to recruit undergraduate students into the space workforce, train them effectively before graduation and retain them in the field after graduation. Hundreds of undergraduates at dozens of schools around the world have directly contributed to missions that operated on-orbit. The spacecraft themselves are capable of performance research-grade science or demonstrate new enabling technologies. This was not always the case. For the first forty years of spaceflight, there were exceedingly few university-class missions; those that flew were expensive, marginally-performing and had modest success rates. What changed? Why are university-class missions now commonplace? And, with respect to on-orbit success, are they as good (or as bad) as rumor and hearsay make them out to be? In this paper and all-too-brief talk, the history of university-class spacecraft will be discussed, with an emphasis on the types of missions and their success rates. Beginning in 1994 (the author's first time attending this conference, as a wide-eyed student) and reaching through to 2018 (the author's 21st, now as a world-weary professor) a statistical and anecdotal review of university-class spacecraft will be presented. Particular attention will be paid to addressing these questions: 1) What kinds of missions have been flown, are being flown and should be flown? 2) What are historical and present-day mission success rates for university-class missions? 3) Why are the mission success rates so poor?
Language: English
Open Access status: green
Award: OUR PROPOSED APPROACH IS TO EXAMINE THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN MISSION COMPLEXITY DEVELOPMENT SCHEDULE AND MISSION SUCCESS. SPECIFICALLY WE BELIEVE THAT WE CAN FIND A CORRELATION BETWEEN THE TIMING OF DEVELOPMENT MILESTONES (E.G. PROGRAM KICKOFF LAUNCH MANIFEST CDR ENGINEERING UNIT FINAL INTEGRATION TESTING AND DELIVERY) THE COMPLEXITY OF THE MISSION AND THE ON-ORBIT SUCCESS. WE EXPECT TO FIND SIGNIFICANTLY HIGHER RATES OF FAILURE AMONG PROGRAMS THAT HAD TO TRUNCATE THEIR TESTING IN ORDER TO MEET THE FIXED LAUNCH DATE. WE BELIEVE THAT THIS INFORMATION WILL HELP US SET UP GUIDELINES TO HELP PROGRAMS SCOPE MISSION COMPLEXITY AGAINST SCHEDULE AND THEIR OWN PROGRAM S CAPABILITIES. WE ATTEMPTED TO COMPLETE THIS TASK DURING THE PERIOD OF PERFORMANCE OF THE LAST GRANT. HOWEVER SIMPLY KEEPING UP WITH THE DATABASE PROVED TO BE MORE THAN ENOUGH WORK GIVEN THE SCOPE OF SUPPORT. WE PROPOSE A NEW APPROACH: SITE VISITS AND/OR INTERVIEWS WITH AT LEAST EIGHT OF THE MOST PROLIFIC DEVELOPERS OF CUBESATS AMONG THE CONSTELLATION CRAFTER AND INDUSTRIAL CATEGORIES. IF WE ARE ABLE TO LEARN ABOUT THEIR APPROACH TO RISK MISSION ASSURANCE PRACTICES PRE-FLIGHT TESTING ETC. WE CAN START ATTACHING REAL INFORMATION TO OUR INFORMED SPECULATION. SHOULD FUNDING BECOME AVAILABLE WE WILL PURSUE A SECOND MAJOR RESEARCH THRUST. IN THE SAME WAY THAT VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY HAS LEVERAGED THE SYSML SPECIFICATION AND THEIR OWN CAPABILITIES TO DEFINE A MODEL-BASED APPROACH TO IDENTIFYING RADIATION-EFFECTS RISKS IN CUBESATS WE BELIEVE THAT THIS APPROACH CAN BE EXPANDED TO COVER ISSUES OF MISSION DESIGN INTEGRATION AND VERIFICATION (I.E. CUBESAT MISSION SUCCESS (2018) 3 SLU:SWARTWOUT THE RISK FACTORS WE THINK ARE THREATENING MANY CUBESAT MISSIONS BEFORE THE RADIATION EFFECTS HAVE THE CHANCE).
OpenAlex ID: W2893524221
FWCI: 5.27
Cites: 10
Cited by: 25
Related to: 10