Year: 2018
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The main purpose of this doctoral thesis is to enhance our understanding, through an in-depth case study, on how to reach enabling formalization with the help of which control systems and related processes could concurrently facilitate efficiency and innovation. In the current knowledge economy, how to better manage such tensions is a key issue in many organizations. To solve this ambidextrous dilemma of formalization, Adler and Borys (1996) introduced the theoretical notion of enabling bureaucracy with four specific characteristics, namely internal transparency, global transparency, repair, and flexibility. Despite the existence of the four enabling features in the case organization’s cybernetic control systems (see Malmi & Brown 2008, 291; Green & Welsh 1988, 289), counterevidence regarding the postulated associations between the four specific characteristics of Adler & Borys (1996) and innovation, and especially its critical component of motivation was obtained. Notions from the psychological self-determination theory (e.g. Deci & Ryan 1985) were thereby brought into the analysis. The theory contends that for autonomous forms of motivation to arise, individual’s three basic needs – competence, autonomy, and relatedness – must be fulfilled (Deci & Ryan 1985). By using abduction in interpreting the acquired case study evidence, I came to appreciate many of the findings of Adler and Borys (1996) as well as Adler and Chen (2011) as the four enabling features supported innovation and autonomous motivation in several ways. While the findings support their view about the encouragement of motivation through internalization of both goals and of the discipline necessary to reach them, they concurrently indicate that the four features may not always be sufficient to support such processes. The basic psychological need of relatedness is in prior literature argued to be highly important for such processes of internalization and, to support it, cybernetic control system systems with relative evaluation processes and pressures can play an important part. I suggest that in the knowledge-intensive case organization, the failure in the internalization of values was associated with relatedness – due to an absence of right kind of pressure through the cybernetic control systems. The organizational members were in a relatively passive way engaged in using prior knowledge rather than enthusiastically creating new knowledge, although the latter was realised to be critical for the company’s future success. It is thereby argued that for managers to adequately support their subordinates’ motivational orientations and subsequent activities of innovation, introducing a right amount of pressure may be critical. However, managers should simultaneously acknowledge the delicate balance of such processes.
Source: UTUPub (University of Turku)
Author: Eero Ståhlberg
Institution: University of Turku
Language: English
Subfield: Accounting
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: ambidexterity, innovation, self-determination theory, autonomous motivation, relatedness, knowledge-intensive organizations, knowledge economy, value internalization, organizational pressure, knowledge production, organizational control, knowledge management, knowledge management systems, organizational structure
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2895984573
