Year: 2018
Type: article
Abstract: Heat stress is a global issue constraining animal agriculture productivity, negatively affects welfare, and reduces production efficiency in many countries. The effects of heat stress on pig production will intensify, if climate change continues as predicted. To date, modifying the environment is the most effective way to mitigate the effects of heat stress. Identifying additional strategies (nutritional and genetics) to maximize pork production during the warm summer months is necessary to satiate a growing demand for high quality meat for human consumption. Heat stress is a major environmental issue negatively affecting animal welfare and production efficiency in almost every livestock sector (Baumgard and Rhoads, 2013). When animals are exposed to environmental conditions that exceed their thermoneutral zone, production efficiency is compromised because the hierarchy of nutrient utilization is reprioritized to maintain euthermia, and consequently productivity is deemphasized. Heat stress is not an issue limited to tropical regions, as temperate countries are also affected during warm summer months (Renaudeau et al., 2012a). In fact, estimated annual losses due to heat stress in the U.S. livestock industry alone is US$1.5 billion for dairy and nearly US$1 billion for swine (Pollmann, 2010; Key and Sneeringer, 2014). Furthermore, increased genetic selection for production traits (i.e., lean tissue accretion, milk yield, and fecundity) leads to reduced heat stress tolerance as these phenotypes are associated with increased metabolic heat production (Renaudeau et al., 2012a; Baumgard and Rhoads, 2013). In the swine industry, economic losses associated with heat stress are mainly explained by reduced and inconsistent growth, decreased feed efficiency, decreased carcass quality (increased lipid deposition and decreased protein accretion), poor sow performance, increased mortality (especially in sows and market hogs) and morbidity, and decreased facility efficiency (Baumgard and Rhoads, 2013; Ross et al., 2015). Reduced reproductive performance is characterized by anestrus, increased wean-to-estrus interval, decreased farrowing rate, and reduced litter size (Ross et al., 2015). Similarly, poor semen production and quality occur in boars exposed to heat stress. Thus, heat stress compromises almost every economically important phenotype within the industry. Although the aforementioned postnatal effects of heat stress are easily recognized and well-defined, the effects of in utero heat stress experienced by the developing piglet on future postnatal production traits are more inconspicuous. Specifically, piglets derived from heat-stressed dams have increased body temperature and accumulate adipose tissue more efficiently during later growth stages at the expense of lean tissue (Johnson et al., 2015; Ross et al., 2017). Both increased body temperature and altered body composition have profound implications on maintenance costs, feed efficiency, ration formulation, and facility efficiency. However, these inefficient phenotypes would be expressed during the following year’s winter and spring and would thus be less remarkable. The prenatal effects of heat stress on future production phenotypes (which are currently not considered in the economic estimates) may ultimately be a larger constraint to efficient pig production than the more distinguishable effects of postnatal heat stress. Globally, pork is one of the most consumed farm animals (Figure 1). China has about half of the pork production (49%), European countries are the second largest in pig production (25%), and North American countries are third with 11% (Figure 2). When considering growth rates between 1990 and 2016, emerging countries (e.g., South America and South Eastern Asia) are expected to contribute more significantly to global pork production with lower growth expected in Europe and North America. Incidentally, many of the aforementioned regions of expected growth in pig production are characterized by long periods of warm and humid conditions. Coupled with a rapidly expanding human population is an expected decrease in poverty rates. In this context, worldwide appetite for pork is expected to increase by 50% by 2050, especially in emerging tropical and subtropical countries. In most cases, the expansion in pig production will be achieved through intensification based on modern management practices and on animals of high genetic merit. Evolution of the world market demand for meat production between 1960 and 2016 (FAO Statistics). Evolution of pig meat production per country across 60 yr (FAO Statistics). Data enclosed in square brackets are the yearly variation in pork production from 1990 to 2016. However, the environment where pork is actually produced is often markedly different from the conditions where the genetic selection occurred. Consequently, climate change combined with the migration of pig production and a suboptimal genetics by environment interaction creates a significant barrier of sustainably meeting the global requirement for animal protein. Animals lose heat in the form of sensible and latent (evaporative) heat. Conduction, convection, and radiation are primary mechanisms sensible heat loss occurs, and each requires a temperature gradient between the animal and its environment (Collier and Gebremedhin, 2015). Therefore, as ambient temperature increases, animals redistribute blood towards the skin in an attempt to increase radiant heat loss. With a further increase in ambient temperature (the temperature gradient between the environment and animal becomes smaller or even negative), the transfer of heat by conductive, convective, and radiative modes decreases. In fact, when ambient temperature increases above the upper critical temperature, evaporation is the only route of heat loss. Swine have few functional sweat glands and their thermoregulatory ability is further complicated by a thick subcutaneous adipose tissue layer, which impedes sensible heat loss; thus, pigs depend more on the respiratory route (i.e., panting) for heat dissipation (Collier and Gebremedhin, 2015). If the efforts of increasing heat loss to maintain euthermia are inadequate, the pig will initiate a variety of strategies to minimize heat production (behavior, etc., discussed below). Normally, adjusting voluntary feed intake is one of the main adaptations employed to modify metabolic heat production in response to ambient temperature changes. Therefore, when ambient temperature increases, euthermia is maintained mainly by increasing heat loss and reducing heat production (Collin et al., 2001). Strategies to reduce heat production include decreasing feed intake and its associated thermic effect of feeding (Quiniou et al., 2000), along with decreased physical activity and reducing basal metabolic rate (Collin et al., 2001). Reduced feed intake is a highly conserved response to heat stress across species (Baumgard and Rhoads, 2013), and in pigs it can be represented as a curvilinear decrease with increasing ambient temperature, but varies depending on genotype, diet composition, body weight, and ambient temperature (Renaudeau et al., 2011). Average daily gain during heat stress is usually reduced, and this is partly a consequence of decreased nutrient intake. Similar to feed intake, average daily gain has a curvilinear response during a thermal load and is affected by the animal’s body weight with heavier pigs more susceptible to heat stress than lighter ones (Renaudeau et al., 2011). As reviewed by Renaudeau et al. (2012b), the effect of heat stress on feed efficiency depends on both the temperature level and pig body weight. For a mild heat stress, feed efficiency generally increases because of the effect of feed restriction on the composition of body weight gain (more lean/less fat). Reduced feed efficiency is reported in finishing pigs kept at a temperature higher than 30 °C. This decrease in feed efficiency is related to a reduced proportion of energy intake available for tissue growth, which is mainly explained by a strong reduction in feed intake. However, regardless of the nuances within the feed efficiency equation, there is no question that heat stress reduces facility and operational efficiency (amount of carcass weight produced per barn per year) as it markedly decreases the time it takes to reach market weight. Interestingly, variations in growth performance during heat stress may also depend on the severity of the heat load and this is especially true when compared with pair-fed thermal neutral controls (Figure 3; Pearce et al., 2013; Sanz Fernandez et al., 2015). During mild heat stress (determined by small increases in body temperature variables and only mild reductions in feed intake), pigs grow slower than the pair-fed controls. However, as the severity of heat stress intensifies (determined by large increases in body temperature variables and severe reductions in feed intake), the heat stress pigs perform better (from a growth perspective) than pair-fed thermal neutral controls. This is energetically perplexing but is likely due to the fact that severe heat stress actually decreases maintenance costs rather than increasing it as reported previously (reviewed in Baumgard and Rhoads (2013) and Johnson et al. (2015)). The effects of increasing severity of heat stress on growth rates when compared with ad libitum feeding in thermal neutral conditions. Despite uncertainties in climate variability, the IPCC Fifth Assessment Report Climate (2009) concluded that the increase in global average surface temperature during the 21st century will likely be almost 5 °C, depending on the greenhouse gas emission scenario. Additionally, it reports that it is “virtually certain” that heat waves will occur more often and last longer, and that extreme precipitation events will become more intense and frequent. The deleterious impact this will have on the pig industry is obvious, but given the large uncertainty in the evolution of greenhouse gas emissions (within the global and local socioeconomic context), attempts to accurately evaluate future economic consequences for pork production in response to the global climate change are difficult. Despite the complexity of the assessment, this information is a prerequisite for developing adaptation strategies and implementing decisions. Regarding the effect of global warming on crop production, most models predict a slight to moderate negative effect on simulated yield, even when beneficial effects of CO2, farm-level adaptations, and future technological yield improvements are accounted for (Parry et al., 2004). However, these simulations do not account for uncertainties related to water availability for irrigation and to the potential impacts of pests, weeds, and others stressors (Tubiello et al., 2007). An often overlooked consequence (likely because it is not well-understood) of heat stress and future climate change is the negative effects it may have on the plants eventually consumed by farm animals (Baumgard et al., 2012). For example, climate variability will likely increase instances of mycotoxin production, especially in temperate climate regions (Magan et al., 2011) and pigs have limited ability to detoxify mycotoxins (Wu et al., 2010). Additionally, the crop’s nutrient composition will likely change as protein content is expected to decrease and digestibility may be negatively affected (Hristov et al., 2018). Regardless, despite the fact that the effects of climate change on composition and digestibility of cereals and protein sources remain relatively vague, the potential for altered nutrient feeding value to negatively affect pig production is real and needs to be incorporated into future predictions. There is already a dire need to develop effective and sustainable management approaches to mitigate the negative effects of heat stress and this is even more important within the context of climate change. Undoubtedly, the primary priority is to modify the animal’s microenvironment and these heat stress abatement strategies are presented below. However, the input cost for optimal cooling technology is often too expensive, and this is particularly true for small stakeholders and farmers in developing countries. Genetic selection for thermal tolerance is one potential strategy to mitigate the effects of heat stress, but this is a long-term solution, and typically accompanied by reduced productivity during thermal–neutral conditions. Identifying flexible management approaches to immediately decrease heat stress susceptibility without negatively influencing traditional production traits would be of great value to global animal agriculture. Dietary supplementation and modifications (discussed below) are easily adjustable tactics that could be utilized by a variety of animal industries and are amenable to diverse production systems. There are multiple engineering solutions and management strategies that can be used to mitigate heat stress, with physical environment modification the most effective. Foremost, facility design, construction, and operation are the initial mechanisms for 1) limiting amplification of ambient conditions and 2) minimizing energy required to remove heat from the system. A facility engineered with factors such as shape and orientation, thermal characteristics of construction materials, and ventilation system in careful consideration creates the foundation in which productivity can be minimally disrupted during heat stress. As mentioned above, the thermal environment describes the parameters that influence thermal (heat) exchange between an animal and its surroundings. As previously explained, sensible heat loss modes (conduction, convection, and radiation) are driven by a temperature gradient and latent heat loss modes (evaporation) by a water vapor pressure gradient between an animal’s outer surface (skin or pelage) and its surroundings. Animal characteristics (i.e., configuration, surface area, and surface temperature) affect all sensible modes (surface emissivity only affects radiation). Environmental characteristics each uniquely affect the different heat loss modes, such as surrounding surface temperatures (conduction and radiation), dry-bulb temperature (convection), air velocity (convection and evaporation), vapor pressure (evaporation), emissivity and orientation of surrounding objects (radiation), and lastly, heat capacity and thermal resistance of contact object (conduction). Therefore, these are the environmental parameters that can be physically modified to reduce heat stress (Figure 4). Thermal (heat) exchange between a pig and its surroundings with prediction of different cooling strategies as they relate to heat exchange. The need to predict and support informed management decisions related to animal performance, health, and well-being has resulted in the development of thermal indices or equivalent (effective) temperatures that represent the effects produced by the heat exchange process. Although these indices substantially simplify complex physical and biological interactions, they serve as useful tools for guiding thermal environment management. For swine, the thermoneutral zone range changes predominately as a function of body mass. This is attributed to the increasing metabolic heat production and the decreasing surface area to mass ratio as a pig grows, albeit body mass is rarely ever used as an input to a thermal index, it is required to accurately assess the thermal environment. Consequently, the exact environmental conditions inducing heat stress in pigs remain ill-defined and this limits the of heat stress abatement management. For reducing the radiation load by is a and or as and can minimize to reduce the surrounding surface temperatures heat to the and not modify the local thermal environment. for include orientation, and and 2012). for they are rarely exposed to it can substantially heat a and to facility heat inducing a higher radiative load 2013). Thus, and are effective at reducing the surface temperature and heat temperature can be reduced a expansion air which of a system and However, the and typically it economically for swine When water changes from to vapor (i.e., evaporation), energy is at As air an energy is from both the and the air as the water decreasing air the air temperature the facility is lower heat for and the as as the water vapor content is of is most used in where cooling demand is and the need for surroundings are 5 and 5 reduce air temperature water The of water that increases with decreasing et al., 2007). usually achieved by at air and of surrounding is generally evaporation can occur in relatively high larger that do not and can surrounding and With all cooling water the evaporation rate, and heat is limited by the of air As to physical modifying the environment to a effective temperature, cooling the increase in heat loss from the body strategies are discussed below. the animal affects both and heat loss. heat loss increases at the square of air as increases, the heat loss Furthermore, a temperature gradient between the animal’s surface temperature and the air temperature for heat loss to swine skin temperature between and °C. Thus, if ambient temperature approaches skin temperature, the of is can be by increasing per of area or the in water to the skin can increase heat loss and if combined with becomes a for heat stress Heat from the animal to the surrounding is to the water (the change requires The transfer of thermal energy from the pig into the water decreases the body water to the skin can be by for larger or for cooling (i.e., sows in a water with can markedly the efficiency of both of heat loss. can lose sensible heat to a of a lower temperature through This is predominately achieved by water through the the pigs sows a of their and this for the of For finishing have with to for water is limited as and operational costs can be in with the of a water and a There are that for the thermal environment and animal to heat stress. and is necessary to decisions heat stress temperature is often the only used to and the thermal environment and this in multiple The main of a for swine is 1) ability to to conditions (i.e., thermal and 2) radiative load radiation can increase the temperature of the and the of a high air this also most likely a high radiative load and the need for additional given the and in swine but and have reduced cost and is due to cost and ability to from air conditions to for cooling radiation is often due to a of the that a with an air temperature at the is the The as an of heat stress are rate, skin temperature, temperature, temperature, and temperature would be an but this is accompanied with for temperature are and temperature, but these requires and and each has potential negative can be human as the and rate in swine has temperature the between metabolic heat production and the heat loss to the surroundings. With to skin temperature, both of the thermal be that heat produced from the animal body temperature, tissue blood skin and temperature) and energy from the animal and latent modes of heat transfer surface area, shape and orientation, and all the environmental Thus, during environmental skin temperature has in the severity of heat stress. represent a and to the negative effects of heat stress and animal management practices include thermic effect of feeding and this is by increasing and reducing the of protein or and the of heat compared with in the large heat and protein is associated with increased heat production, minimizing and accurately protein and during the warm summer months pigs with a heat et al., 2015). be that these are in large and are not as and as In fact, et al. reported that performance in growing pigs exposed to of heat stress not affected by a Consequently, the needs that diet during the warm summer strategies that have their requirement et al., 2013). of the negative consequences that heat stress has on animal and productivity are by reduced barrier (Baumgard et al., Baumgard and Rhoads, 2013). As already during heat stress there is a of blood to the in an attempt to increase heat loss. Consequently, the in an to support the altered blood and the reduced blood and nutrient creates barrier a local if severe associated with and an protein Consequently, heat stress is in large an response by Thus, strategies to or minimize are of and include (i.e., and (i.e., Additionally, functional that have effects could production during heat stress and these include and As above, heat stress susceptibility will if genetic selection continues to traditional production as these are associated with increased heat heat susceptibility to be a in finishing and genetics may a strategy to production during the warm summer The biological and to heat stress represent an complex for which genetic information is In many significant regions in with heat tolerance in pigs et al., 2017). This information could be used in the future to pigs of high of productivity during heat stress. However, there a and a critical need to of the genetic to the variation in response to heat stress. In heat stress compromises a variety of production parameters in the swine industry growth, carcass composition, and that to heat stress has effects on postnatal The of climate change increased pork production in tropical and subtropical regions of the and genetic capacity for lean tissue and all to negative impacts of heat stress on pork production efficiency and quality in the modifying the environment is currently the primary abatement strategy that be utilized to mitigate the negative effects of heat stress, but approaches include modifications and genetic is a in the of Animal at on the effects of environmental on and growth performance in is from where the of for in Animal a in Animal at Renaudeau is a in the and for the Animal and between and is the and The main of is to and about animal dairy with on and has more than yr of on the adaptation of the pigs to thermal heat stress. is an in the of and at and swine and production with a on and energy efficiency, animal environmental and livestock is in and of the thermal environment and air quality parameters that affect animal a and from the of at and is from Ross is the in in the of Animal at and of the and approaches to from which the will livestock and associated industries swine production efficiency. efforts include genetic modification of pigs to the genetic of phenotypes associated with production efficiency and to the of pigs as Ross at and at and a at the of Baumgard is the in the of Animal at efforts are in Environmental and is on heat stress reduces farm animal activity and to develop strategies to heat stress.
Source: Animal Frontiers
DOI: 10.1093/af/vfy035
Language: English
Subfield: Animal Science and Zoology
Domain: Life Sciences
Keywords: heat stress, pigs, thermoneutral zone, heat tolerance, in utero heat stress, maternal effects, sow reproductive performance, piglet growth, feed efficiency, carcass characteristics, heat stress mitigation, climate change, genetic selection, nutritional strategies, animal welfare, pork production
SDG: Zero hunger
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $3,500
OpenAlex ID: W2898828257
