Work

The Melodic Mind: Neural bases of intonation in speech and music

Year: 2017
Type: dissertation
Abstract: factual message of an utterance (Cutler, Dahan, & Van Donselaar, ); it also plays a major role in conveying "unspoken" messages on its own.While intonational phonologists (Bolinger, ) and developmental psychologists (Malloch & Trevarthen, a) have been aware of the communicative power of prosody for quite some time, comparably little is known about the neurocognitive bases of the melodic communicative channel.The first goal of the thesis is, therefore, to describe the neurocognitive architecture that en-Lintfert, Dogil, & Möbius, ).Knowledge about these conventions provides common ground for both receivers and senders and fosters seamless interactions (Pickering & Garrod,). Crucially, it not only guides listeners' perception, but equally determines melodic and prosodic choices in the sender to make herself properly understood, within the realms of aesthetics and social adequacy.While melody and prosody perception have been addressed by cognitive neuroscientists in the past (Koelsch, a; Schirmer & Kotz, ), available data on neural correlates of their production remain sparse (Pichon & Kell, ; Zatorre, Chen, & Penhune, ).The third goal of the thesis is, therefore, to lend neuro-behavioural evidence for the role of pitch-based conventions in driving performers' actions leading them to produce melodically well-formed signals that facilitate social interaction and communication.Part I Framework and summary Chapter Use of pitch in speech and music Modulation of pitch in speech and music is a springboard for humans to grow into socioemotionally and linguistically competent individuals.Infants are born with a remarkable sensitivity for pitch and melody (Perani et al., ; Stefanics et al., ): From early on, they pick up on the emotional tone in lullabies (Trehub & Trainor, ) and maternal speech (Grossmann, Oberecker, Koch, & Friederici, ) that regulate their own emotions.-day old newborns can already recognize (Mehler et al., ) and imitate pitch patterns of their native language (Mampe, Friederici, Christophe, & Wermke, ), which they start to use intentionally at the end of their first year of life to regulate cooperative social interactions with their parents while their verbal abilities are still limited (Esteve-Gibert & Prieto, ; Prieto, Estrella, Thorson, & del Mar Vanrell, ).Ultimately, infants benefit in various ways from intonation in infant-directed speech for language acquisition (Graf Estes & Hurley, ; Männel & Friederici, ; Thiessen, Hill, & Saffran, ).Hence, it seems no coincidence that parents around the world sing for their children (Trehub & Trainor, ) and engage in "musical" conversations with their babies (Malloch & Trevarthen, a).They use expanded pitch contours in music and speech to match the little listeners' perceptual capabilities and preferences (Cruttenden, ; Fernald & Kuhl,), fostering social bonding and the language faculty as main pillars of human companionship.Early child development is perhaps the most obvious example for the centrality of melody and pitch for human society and culture-the present thesis will make a strong case on their persistent role in adulthood, as continuous support for language (Chapter ) and . .Prior clarifications: What is melody in speech and music?overview, see Patel, ).Notably, these fixed frequency relations apply both vertically and horizontally, i.e., to consecutive as well as simultaneously sounding pitches (chords), yet another point that finds no correspondence in speech and is denoted as harmony.Most importantly, pitches in music, but not speech, differ in their function that depends on the tonal key they belong to and determines their melodic and harmonic relationship with preceding, concurrent and forthcoming elements of the musical piece.One tone or chord (the tonic), for example, acts as central reference point of a tonal key and is characterized by highest stability in a piece, while stability of the remaining tones or chords of the scale varies hierarchically (Krumhansl,).These (and other) relationships are sometimes referred to as "musical syntax" (Swain, ) that governs the rule-based arrangement of discrete pitches into musically meaningful sequences (Lerdahl & Jackendoff,) and allows listeners (and performers) to build up expectations upon forthcoming elements (Studies III and VIII).Confirmation and violation of these expectations when moving through tonal pitch space is an archetypical musical process and the source of musical pleasure (Huron, ).Altogether, musical use of pitch compared to speech intonation engenders a much richer set of vertical and horizontal pitch relations that hold interest and are memorable on their own, even if fused with words (see Studies V and VI).Nevertheless, to put it in Dwight Bolinger's words "since intonation is synonymous with speech melody, and melody is a term borrowed from music, it is natural to wonder what connection there may be between music and intonation" (Bolinger, : ; cf.Patel, : ).There are (at least) three aspects that melodies in music and speech have in common and that are relevant for the present thesis: the processing of pitch contour (as opposed to intervals), the grouping of elements into phrases, and the power to convey interpersonal meaning without pointing to items in the objective world.Pitch contour refers to the global direction of pitch changes irrespective of their exact size.Other than fixed intervals, contour is processed from early infancy on (Fernald & Kuhl, ; Stefanics et al., ; Trainor & Trehub, ), is more readily remembered and reproduced (Dowling, , ) and can be preserved despite deficits in musical interval processing after brain damage (Liégeois-Chauvel, Peretz, Babai, Laguitton, & Chauvel, The present thesis will use the terms melody and harmony even-handedly to refer to the arrangement of pitch elements into musical sequences, irrespective of whether elements are single tones or simultaneously sounding pitches (i.e., chords).Note that both types of sequences underlie similar compositional principles denoted as musical "syntax".Note that more than half of the world's languages are tone languages, such as Mandarin Chinese, Thai, or Yoruba, in which pitch contours determine the lexical meaning of speech sounds (Haspelmath, Dryer, Gil, & Comrie, ).Lexical use of pitch and its neural processing are not topic of the present thesis, but are reviewed in Gandour and Krishnan ( ).Chapter .Use of pitch in speech and music ; Peretz, ; Schuppert, Münte, Wieringa, & Altenmüller, ) suggestive of dissociated neural substrates (Stewart, Overath, Warren, Foxton, & Griffiths, ).Hence, compared to fixed intervals, global contour perception seems to be the more basic process that may be common to both speech and music.Several findings have fuelled this idea: spoken speech, when repeated, can be perceived as sung (Deutsch, Henthorn, & Lapidis, ; S.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2899082463
Cites: 702
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10