Year: 2005
Type: article
Abstract: Every day in the United States the following scenario is repeated countless times.A lawyer challenges a potential juror.The opposing party objects, arguing that the juror was challenged on the basis of the juror's race or gender.The judge then asks the deceptively simple question, "Why?Why did you challenge that juror?"The lawyer responds, in good faith and as truthfully as she can, with a race-or gender-neutral reason.The vast majority of the time the judge believes the lawyerafter all, she will appear credible, since she believes she is telling the truthand the peremptory challenge is upheld.But what if the lawyer is wrong?What if her awareness of her mental processes is imperfect?What if she does not know, or even cannot know, that, in fact, but for the juror's race or gender, she would not have exercised the challenge?This article examines the findings from recent psychological research to conclude that the lawyer often will be wrong, will be unaware of her mental processes, and would not have exercised the challenge but for the juror's race or gender.As a result (and not because of lying lawyers), the Batson peremptory challenge framework is woefully ill-suited to address the problem of race and gender discrimination injury selection.Current reform proposals are hit or miss, because they do not directly address this source of injustice.Although abolishing the peremptory challenge would be optimal, in the alternative this article recommends several steps that lawyers and judges should take to reduce the impact of unconscious bias on jury selection.8 See BLACK'S LAW DICTIONARY 1136 (6th ed.1990) (defining a peremptory challenge as "[t]he right to challenge a juror without assigning, or being required to assign, a reason for the challenge").A later edition defined the peremptory challenge as one "that need not 2005] 2005] 20 See infra Part II.A. 21 See infra notes 173-185 and accompanying text.22 See infra Part III.B-C.23 See infra Part III.D.
Source: FIU Law Review
Author: Antony Page
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2903029837
