Work

Transition from supraglottic to infraglottic rescue in the “can’t intubate can’t oxygenate”(CICO) scenario

Year: 2014
Type: report
Abstract: The focus of each paper is as follows: Part 0: Introduction, defi nitions and methodology Overview• Provides contextual information, defi nes the key terms used in this series and outlines the methods employed in the literature searches.Part 1: Mortality and evidence of sub-optimal care arising from CICO events Overview• Reviews the published literature for evidence of impact of CICO events on mortality and patient safety including evidence that the event is managed sub-optimally. Key fi ndings• There is suffi cient evidence to feel concerned that clinicians, including anaesthetists, other critical care clinicians and their teams, are not suffi ciently prepared to prevent, recognise and or manage a CICO event.Part 2: Clinical criteria for infraglottic rescue Overview• Examines what, if any, clinical criteria support a decision to declare a CICO event prompting a shift in the focus of management from supraglottic to infraglottic rescue. Key fi ndings• Several position papers, decision-support algorithms and cognitive aids have been published that provide guidance on the prevention and management of airway obstruction.• Close inspection reveals reasonably strong agreement that a CICO event should be declared in conjunction with failed supraglottic rescue -this includes manoeuvres related to facemask ventilation, endotracheal intubation and ventilation via supraglottic rescue devices such as the laryngeal mask airway.• They differ in the extent to which they emphasise these three above-mentioned groups of manoeuvres and in respect to whether and by how much they quantify a maximum number of attempts in relation to them.A range of two to four attempts is recommended for endotracheal intubation and up to two attempts for insertion of supraglottic airway devices.This series recommends no more than three attempts at endotracheal intubation and no more than two attempts at insertion of laryngeal mask airways, the most commonly used supraglottic airway devices in Australia and New Zealand.• Some guidelines recommend that oxygen should be delivered via a supraglottic route without interruption, where possible and an exit strategy such as awakening the patient is observed. Part 3: The role of human factors Overview• Presents evidence that associates human factors with enablers and barriers to the prevention and management of CICO, including organisational (systems) safety, cognitive performance and team behaviours. Key points• Organisational, individual and team factors are strongly interrelated human factors that contribute substantially to prevention and management of airway emergencies including CICO.• Clinicians are vulnerable to errors resulting from unproductive cognitive processes or factors such as stress fatigue and high task workload that reduce cognitive resources and lead to errors.Clinicians should monitor their performance for these effects.Activation of pre-prepared responses and effective crisis behaviours should be employed to optimise these factors.• Teamwork is vital to ensure tasks are executed in a timely well co-ordinated manner without errors.Team members promote good performance by being knowledgeable of the practice guidelines, rehearsed in their execution, and prepared to support team leaders in an evolving emergency.This requires them to speak up if concerned.The behaviour of the team leader and culture within the team will enable or inhibit this.Team leaders should encourage other team members to speak up if concerned and this advice should be written into cognitive aids.• Finally, clinicians should practise in environments that are conducive to good performance.These include using evidence-based locally relevant guidelines, resources, equipment and communications systems with which they have been trained.They should have access to other experts.Ideally they should train in teams but at a minimum should adhere to a common set of guidelines and procedures.The physical environment of the operating theatre or setting in which airway management occurs should be optimised to promote team co-ordination and situation awareness through display of cognitive aids, layout of relevant equipment, team leadership and effective emergency communication, the latter including briefi ngs and updates and closed loop communication. Part 4: Management of transition Overview• Looks at the evidence from parts 1, 2 and 3 recommends strategies contributing to minimisation or mitigation of CICO. Key pointsIn order for clinicians to be prepared for this event, multiple performance shaping factors must be optimised. Part 5: Features of cognitive aids that best support the management of CICO Overview• Evaluates the evidence for the routine use of cognitive aids (CAs) in CICO events and their design features. Key points• Several position papers, decision-support algorithms and cognitive aids have been published that provide guidance on the transition from supraglottic rescue to infraglottic rescue in airway emergencies.However, not all of these specify whether their intended use is to guide training and rehearsal conducted in preparation of an emergency; to guide decision-making and performance during an airway emergency; or some other purpose such as standard setting and or quality assurance activities.It is unlikely that a guideline, presented in a single format, could achieve all of these purposes.In particular, content rich documents that are effective as training guides are not well suited to be used in real-time to support decisionmaking or prevent common errors such as memory failure, communication errors and assertiveness issues.• There is a role for simple cognitive aids whose purpose is to be used at the bedside to remind people of the more detailed decision-aids they have used in training activities, prompt users to follow best practice at high-risk points and prevent key performance errors during an evolving emergency.• Drawing from evidence presented in this series the key recommended features and inclusions of a cognitive aid for CICO are listed below.The aid should:
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2904119364
Cites: 53
Cited by: 32
Related to: 10