Work

What Makes Organization

Year: 2012
Type: article
Abstract: This article investigates a segmentation model used by the Danish Tax and Customs\nAdministration to classify businesses’ motivational postures. The article uses two different\nconceptualizations of performativity to analyze what the model’s segmentations do; Hacking’s\nidea of making up people and MacKenzie’s idea of performativity. Based on these two approaches\nI demonstrate that the segmentation model represents and performs the businesses as it ‘makes up’\ncertain new ways to be a business and as the businesses can be seen as ‘moving targets’. With\ninspiration from MacKenzie my following argument is that the segmentation model posits a\nremarkable cleverness in that it simultaneously alters what it represents and represents this\naltered reality to confirm the accuracy of its own model of the businesses’ postures. However,\ndespite this cleverness the model bears a blind spot as it assumes a world wherein everything\naround the model is in motion and can be shaped, whereas it believes itself to be stable. As\nindicated in the article, this assumption turns out problematic as the tax administration questions\nthe model’s ability to produce valid comparisons. All in all, the article provides a detailed\ndescription and analysis of the model’s performativity and provides an example of a\nperformativity study which in its methodology differs from the methodological criteria set up by\nMacKenzie.
Author: Karen Boll
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2906135722
FWCI:
Cites: 207
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10