Year: 2018
Type: preprint
Study designs: Systematic Review, Meta-Analysis
Abstract: The paper is a meta-analysis of experimental studies dealing with the impact of incidental emotions on risky choices, so as to explain traditional heterogeneity of outcomes in the field. After devising a standard search strategy and filtering out studies that do not match a list of selection criteria, I include 20 manuscripts from which 54 observations are drawn at the treatment level. At this point, I code a set of moderator variables representing experimental protocols and calculate Cohen’s d effect size as dependent variable of a weighted least squares (WLS) regression where larger studies are given more weight. Among the results, I find that emotions induce greater risk-taking when the mood induction procedure consists in the viewing of film clips in place of other techniques, as well as in case risk preferences are elicited in the negative instead of positive domain. Stated and revealed preferences turn out to be equally valid risk elicitation methods, while the use of games instead of tasks does not influence behavior. Given the variety of protocols employed in this type of experiments and in the absence of a tailor-made task to answer such research questions, I recommend faithful study replication as preferential path in order to further investigate the influence of emotions on risky decision making and ensure comparability.
Author: Matteo M. Marini
Language: English
Subfield: General Decision Sciences
Field: Decision Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2907380444
