Between the city and the village: thedifferential impact of the predatory andabsentee state on indigenous land rightsand deforestation in Bangladesh and India
Year: 2018
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Smallholders in the Global South are often excluded from their land rights by exclusionary policies of\nconservation, which are intensifying in the face of a changing climate. Such conflicts are often the\nmost problematic where they overlap with the extant political-marginalisation of the smallholder,\narticulated in ethnic terms. The world’s Indigenous Peoples, being among the most vulnerable to\ndispossession while also tending to inhabit forested spaces, are of central importance to these\ndebates.\nSouth Asia comprises a “natural laboratory” of different institutional arrangements that mediate the\nrelationship between the State and the land and forestry rights of Indigenous Peoples. This study\nuses ethnographic methods, remote sensing analysis of forest cover change and archival research to\ntest whether this institutional variation leads to differences in dispossession and deforestation, and\noffer conclusions as to why this is the case.\nThe Garo community inhabits both Meghalaya state in India and the Madhupur region of\nBangladesh, with strong and weak legal protections over lands and forests respectively. The study\nfinds that dispossession and deforestation outcomes are worse in Bangladesh than in India. This\ndifference results institutionally from a lack of recognition of the legitimacy of Garo land rights in\nMadhupur which in turn stems from the local, ethnically-bounded political-economy, the “Predatory\nState”. This comprises an assemblage of local political elites and State bureaucrats for whom both\nthe Garo smallholding and the original forest represent untapped resources that dispossession\nreleases into the dominant political-economy.\nIn contrast, Garo land rights are afforded full legal recognition in Meghalaya, resulting in low levels\nof dispossession and a conservation regime that is robust because ownership of protected areas\nremains vested in the community. This situation is deteriorating as land values increase, due to an\n“Absentee State” that does not provide robust and accessible dispute resolution processes, resulting\ninstitutionally in community rights being only partially embedded in the wider administrative\nstructure. The main underlying cause is that institutional dysfunction was deliberately designed into\nthe system to allow the State to “recentralise while decentralising”.
Author: Oliver Scanlan
Institution: Dublin City University
Language: English
Subfield: Global and Planetary Change
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2907475373
