Work

Treatment of depression: empirical evidence from a clinical trial comparing narrative therapy with cognitive-behavioral therapy

Year: 2014
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Background: Major depressive disorder (MDD) is a serious problem and research on new interventions is required. White and Epston's (1990) narrative therapy (NT) is a psychotherapeutic approach based on the notion that people construct narratives in order to define themselves and give meaning to their life experiences. MDD is featured by the construction of narratives saturated by negative meanings, such as failures, entrapment and powerlessness, and a hopeless view of the future. The purpose of psychotherapy is to help clients shape new identities and construct stories in a richer and more diverse way. Although familiar amongst clinicians and widely practiced, systematic studies of the efficacy of NT for depression are sparse, especially those using large client samples and quantitative research methods. To our knowledge only one study examined the efficacy of NT and none has compared NT treatment directly to a control group or another intervention in the same clinical setting. On the other hand, cognitive-behavior therapy (CBT) is the most established psychological treatment for depression so far. Aims: The primary purpose of this doctoral dissertation is to assess the efficacy of manualized NT for depression and compare it with CBT. Additionally, we aimed to compare the time to improve from depressive symptoms and interpersonal problems during treatments and during follow-up. Methods: Ten therapists with different levels of experience and 63 clients diagnosed with mild and moderate MDD took part in this study. Clients were assigned to treatments quasi-randomly. Therapist’s adherence to manuals and competence were assured by weekly supervision and by the completion of a scale by independent judges, after having watched taped sessions. The Beck Depression Inventory-II and Outcome Questionnaire-45.2 were used as outcome measures. Results: Both treatments were superior to benchmarked waiting-list control groups in alleviating depressive symptoms for those clients who completed treatment. There is a significant difference favoring CBT when dropouts are included in the analysis. A detailed analysis of the dropout sample confirmed that although treatment assignment did not predict dropout, CBT dropouts had significantly better outcomes than NT dropouts. Also, clients taking medication at intake were 80% less likely to drop out from psychotherapy, compared to those who were not taking medication and clients presenting anxious comorbidity at intake were 82% less likely to drop out compared to those not presenting anxious comorbidity. The follow-up evaluation revealed no differences between treatments and also that half of clients remained free from depressive symptoms after 31 months while the other half still presented depressive symptoms at a dysfunctional range. A survival analytic approach showed that four sessions were necessary for 50% improvement and 16 sessions for 50% recovery, regardless of treatment allocation. Moreover, depressive symptoms were consistently alleviated earlier than interpersonal problems, regardless of treatment assignment. At follow-up, clients keep improving depressive symptoms but not interpersonal problems. Discussion: The concept of narrative has gained increasing importance in the fields of psychotherapy theory, research and practice. Data was not consistent enough to fully ascertain the efficacy of NT, but it was shown that when clients completed treatment, NT is a promising treatment for mild and moderate depression. Replications by independent researchers are needed, especially focusing on the prevention of treatment dropout.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W291484429
Cites: 229
Cited by: 2
Related to: 9