Work

Detection of social agents: the role of kinematic cues

Year: 2018
Type: article
Abstract: A central issue in developmental cognitive science is to understand how cognition develops and changes over time to reach an adult level of specialization. Determining the abilities with which infants come equipped into the world, their mechanisms for acquiring knowledge, and whether and how these abilities change as a function of development and experience is a challenging issue. Since humans are intensely social creatures and they tend to rely on visual signals for communicating psychological dispositions, intentions and emotions, the study of how our system becomes specialized to detect and recognize others is an interesting field of research. A fundamental human social ability is the capacity to accurately detect and understand the intentional conduct of others, to anticipate their upcoming actions, and to appropriately adjust their own behavior (Gallese, Rochat, Cossu, & Sinigaglia, 2009). Particularly, face and body motion represent primary social cues and it has been demonstrated that adults’ brain has a specific neural network that supports detection and recognition of conspecifics and their actions (Adolphs, 2009). From an ontogenetic perspective, the ability to read behavioral cues may be regarded as the fundamental precursors of more sophisticated social cognitive abilities (Gallese et al., 2009). Indeed, there is no doubt that before attributing goals, desires, dispositions to social agents, humans need to detect them in the environment and they need to use perceptual cues that allow them to discriminate animate versus inanimate objects. One of the most powerful cues that attract attention since birth is motion. Moreover, motion of living being has specific features that are not shared with motion of inanimate objects. Considering motion as a fundamental feature that human species might use to detect others and within the Neo/Neuro-constructivist theoretical framework, the purpose of my PhD dissertation is to test the role of kinematic cues in detection of social agents. Particularly, my hypothesis is that our visual system, since birth, possesses some attentional biases towards specific cues of motion that characterize animate entities. These low-level biases are the building blocks, on which during development, infants built their ability to infer other intentions. In this vein, the experience during the first months of life, plays a central role in shaping how our species can use kinematics information, and also in shaping the system to become specialized in processing social information. With this consideration in mind, my thesis begins with a theoretical chapter describing the Neo/Neuro-constructivist approach and how it explains the origin of social brain and social cognition in humans. Subsequently, in the second part of the thesis I will describe a series of experiments aimed at testing the hypothesis of the presence of low-level attentional biases towards cues of motion that characterize human motion since birth (Chapter 2). Using both the visual preference and the visual habituation techniques, the aim of the experiments presented in Chapter 2 was to investigate to which motion cues that in adults elicit animacy perception, the human visual system is sensitive since birth. On the basis of previous evidence showing that human infants, adults and even newly hatched chicks seem to use dynamic cues such as self-propulsion, change in direction, (Mascalzoni, Regolin & Vallortigara, 2010) and speed changes to discriminate between animate and inanimate entities (Tremoulet & Feldman, 2000; Lou & Baillargeron 2005) human newborns without any previous experience have been tested, (Experiment 1; Experiment 2). Collected data demonstrate that at birth also human newborns are sensitive to these cues. Furthermore, results from Experiment 3, 4, 5, and 6, demonstrate that newborns possess an innate predisposition towards a specific acceleration-deceleration pattern of kinematic (Experiment 5), and they do not manifest any preference towards a single speed change (Experiment 3, and 4) or when the order of presentation of acceleration-deceleration is inverted (Experiment 6). These results have been interpreted as suggesting that newborns possess some attentional biases towards cues of motion that characterize animate entities. This inborn sensitivity towards self-propulsion and acceleration-deceleration pattern of motion allows the system to focus attention towards these specific cues of motion also when they are embedded in complex arrays. Previous evidence demonstrates that newborns and infants manifest a sensitivity toward these motion cues also when they are embedded in a complex array of dots (i.e. Simion, Regolin & Bulf, 2008; Bardi, Regolin & Simion, 2011). Moreover, evidence collected with adults demonstrates that when the complex array of dots depicts a walking human figure, adults can retrieve multiple information form it such as walking direction (Bardi, Di Giorgio, Lunghi, Troje & Simion 2015). In light of this, the aim of the experiments described in Chapter 3, was to test whether the information of directionality conveyed by a complex array of dots can trigger orienting of attention in infancy. Specifically, a cueing paradigm was employed (Posner, 1980) and target locked event related responses (ERPs; HD Geodesic System) were recorded. Data from Experiments 7, and 8 demonstrated that the ability to use walking direction to orient attention towards the peripheral space is an ability that emerges from 6 months of age. Moreover, ERPs results indicate that 6-month-old infants, as well as adults, show a modulation of sensory components when a peripheral target appeared in a congruent position with walking direction (Experiment 8 and 9) demonstrating that walking direction can yield a gain control or selective amplification of the sensory information in the extra-cortical visual pathways. Overall, these data demonstrate that detection of social agents relies upon motion cues and that our visual system is tuned, since birth, to specific cues of motion that define human kinematics. It is hypothesized that these cues of motion might be the building blocks on which our species infer and extract intentions of others (Biro & Leslie 2007; Carey, 2009) and that the experience with conspecific might shape our ability to use motion cues to orient attention toward the surrounding space. These conclusions are in line with the Neo/Neuro-Constructivist theory of cognitive development and suggest that experience with conspecifics play a fundamental role in shaping the human system that become specialized in detecting social agents.
Author: Marco Lunghi
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2921617680
FWCI:
Cites: 155
Cited by:
Related to: 10