Work

New evidence on the effect of cash-for-care benefit on maternal labor supply

Year: 2018
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: The purpose of this thesis is to investigate the implications of cash-for-care eligibility on maternal labor supply and to find out if these effects are persistent over time. The cash-for-care benefit in Norway studied in this paper is a benefit paid monthly to parents of children between the age of one and two years who do not, or only partially, attend a government subsidized kindergarten. This benefit was partially introduced to compensate parents that did not manage to secure a slot in kindergarten. However, today there is almost full kindergarten coverage, which gives a real choice between enrolling a child in kindergarten or arranging alternative care and receiving the benefit. This thesis investigates who chooses to use this benefit and why. Previous research finds that it is mainly used by those with low education and income, where a high percentage of the recipients are immigrants. The dissertation builds on the neoclassical model of labor-leisure choice to analyze the use of the benefit. The theory predicts that those with low wages will have a higher incentive compared to those with high wages to leave the labor force, because the economic opportunities provided by the welfare system to those with low wages is better than those presented by the labor market. Building on previous research findings and new analyses, the thesis investigates whether the benefit is economic preferable, and whether the theory can predict the findings. The empirical analysis looks at the effects of the cash-for-care benefit removal for two-year olds in 2012 and exploits the change in benefit entitlements before and after the removal. By examining how comparison in eligibility rates affects labor supply, one can estimate the policy response. This is done by using a fixed effects approach. To conduct this analysis, data from Statistics Norway’s registers have been used. Mothers’ labor supply is measured through mothers’ earnings and the independent variable is cash-for-care eligibility. There is no possibility for reverse causality, as the decision to eliminate the benefit for two-year olds in 2012 was decided upon on processing of the 2012 government budget, such that the children were already born, and the parents could not affect the children’s birth. This provides exogenous variation in cash-for-care eligibility. The empirical analysis finds that a 1 NOK increase in cash-for-care eligibility causes around a 0.20 NOK decrease in mothers’ earnings the year the children turn two years. This is a larger estimate than several other previous estimates, especially compared to Langset et. Al in 2000, who predicted a reduction in labor supply between 5.83% and 7.50%, and also compared to Hardoy and Schøne in 2010, who found a reduction of around 8.00%. The results also indicate that these effects are larger for mothers with low education, compared to those with midrange education when their children are one year. In addition, mothers with partners reduce their labor supply more than non-partner mothers when the children are two years. The analysis of persistency indicates that the negative results on maternal labor supply also remain when the children turn three and four years. A 1 NOK higher cash-for-care eligibility rate causes around a 0.23 and 0.25 NOK decrease in labor earnings when the children are three and four years respectively. These estimates are contradictory to previous findings, especially of what Schøne found in 2004, as no lasting effects of cash-for-care benefit were revealed. In order to investigate which margins of income that are affected by the cash-for-care eligibility, earnings above some base rate thresholds are used as the dependent variable. This shows that at almost all thresholds, earnings fall slightly with some percentage points when there is an increase in cash-for-care eligibility of 1,000 NOK. This also suggests that the effects are rather linear in earnings, which contradicts previous research, including the findings of Hardoy and Schøne from 2010. They found that those already outside the labor market were much more affected by the benefit than those that were active in the labor force. There is a great amount of political debates in Norway on cash-for-care benefit. The results from this analysis are immensely relevant to whether the benefit should be phased out also for the one-year olds.
Language: English
Subfield: Gender Studies
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2923311507
Cites: 11
Cited by:
Related to: 10