Evaluate the effectiveness and sustainability of OptiMal as a self-management intervention for cancer survivors
Year: 2019
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Background: The National Cancer Registry Ireland (NCRI, 2014) has projected that cancer diagnoses will double by 2040 in particular incidences of lung, rectal, colon cancer and melanoma are set to increase substantially.The risk of dying from cancer has decreased by 1% per year leading cancer survival rates to increase (NCRI, 2013).This infers that the number of cancer survivors in Ireland will increase.There are currently 150,000 cancer survivors in Ireland (Department of Health (DOH), 2017).Due to early detection and effective treatment, cancer is considered more a chronic rather than a fatal illness (McCorkle, Erocolano, Lazenby, Green, Schilling & Lorig, 2011).Many cancer survivors experience problems such as pain, fatigue, cognitive difficulties, anxiety and depression following treatment (Shneerson, Taskila, Holder, Greenfield, Tolosa, Damery & Gale, 2014).This can impact upon survivors' abilities to perform everyday activities and affect quality of life (Silver & Gilchrist, 2011).Research recommends that self-management and rehabilitation models used with long-term chronic conditions should be evaluated with cancer survivors, as similar health issues exist and both require long-term follow-up (Elliott, Fallows, Staetsky, Smith, Foster & Maher et al. 2011).Occupational therapists are familiar with the content delivered in self-management programmes (Hwang, Lokietz, Lozano & Parke, 2015).OptiMal is a six-week, occupation-based, self-management intervention originally designed for people with chronic conditions to develop self-management knowledge and skills (O'Toole, Connolly & Smith, 2013;Garvey, Connolly, Boland & Smith, 2015).The aim of this research is to evaluate OptiMal's effectiveness and sustainability with cancer survivors.Methodology: Three studies were undertaken as part of this research.Study I consisted of a systematic review to explore the type, content and effectiveness of self-management interventions previously provided to cancer survivors.This review was guided by the PRISMA guidelines (Moher, Liberati, Tetzlaff, & Altman, 2009).Study II consisted of a mixed-methods study to compare the effectiveness and sustainability of OptiMal, in a group of adult cancer survivors and compare with a control group of cancer survivors.The primary outcome measure was frequency of activity participation.Secondary measures included health-related quality of life, self-efficacy, perception of occupational performance, anxiety, depression, cognitive difficulties and fatigue.Data collection took iv place at baseline, post-intervention and at three months follow-up.Focus groups were held with participants who attended OptiMal, post-intervention and at three months follow-up, to explore the acceptability of the programme.Due to slow recruitment rates, Study III, a qualitative study, was conducted to explore reasons for declining to attend OptiMal.Results: Six studies were included in the final analysis of the systematic review.Three studies reported significant differences between groups, however these interventions lacked sustainability.Due to the diversity of the interventions, it was not possible to draw definitive conclusions on the impact of self-management interventions previously carried out with cancer survivors.In Study II, 80 participants were recruited into the mixedmethods study.Four OptiMal programmes were facilitated over a 15-month period.Eighteen participants (22.5%) were lost at follow-up.Sixty-two participants completed selfreporting questionnaires at all three time points and were included in the final analysis.No significant results were observed in the primary outcome measure; frequency of activity participation.Significant results were observed from baseline to three months follow-up, between the control and intervention group, in health-related quality of life (p<0.001,p=0.035) and anxiety (p=0.04).Cancer survivors reported a lack of follow-up care posttreatment to manage persistent symptoms.OptiMal was considered an acceptable intervention but many reported preferring to receive it within the first year of finishing treatment.In Study III, 12 cancer survivors who previously declined to participate in Study II, participated in semi-structured interviews to explore reasons for non-participation in the mixed-methods study.Survivors reported developing their own self-management strategies to manage continuing symptoms or reported a lack of perceived need for selfmanagement education.Conclusion: Cancer survivors can experience continuing symptoms, particularly psychosocial symptoms, post-treatment which can impact on their participation in daily activities and affect quality of life.Cancer survivors report a need for follow-up care following treatment.OptiMal was considered an acceptable intervention.It empowered survivors with self-management knowledge and skills to increase their participation in daily activities and assist with the transition from cancer treatment to survivorship.Further research is required to conduct a definitive randomised controlled trial with a larger group of mixed cancer survivors earlier post-treatment, to determine the effectiveness and sustainability of OptiMal.However, some cancer survivors reported a lack of need for selfmanagement interventions.Further research is required to identify those in need of selfmanagement.
Author: Lauren Boland
Language: English
Topic: Cancer survivorship and care
Subfield: Oncology
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Keywords: OptiMAL, self-management interventions, cancer survivors, occupational therapy, intervention effectiveness, intervention sustainability, activities and participation, health-related quality of life, chronic disease, cancer rehabilitation, pain, anxiety and depression, cancer survivorship, cancer incidence projections, occupational therapy education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2925192337
