Work

Disaster Governance : Analyzing inconvenient realities and chances for resilience and sustainability

Year: 2019
Type: dissertation
Abstract: English summary Disaster governance Analyzing inconvenient realities and chances for resilience and sustainability A social-ecological systems approach to disaster governance In many places in the world, people are increasingly exposed to disasters. A few recent disasters illustrate the global magnitude of the problem: the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010, the earthquake, tsunami and nuclear disaster in Fukushima, Japan in 2011, typhoon Hajyan in the Philippines in 2013, hurricane Irma in the Caribbean in 2017, the earthquakes in Nepal in 2015, the volcano eruption in Guatemala in 2018 and the earthquake and tsunami in Indonesia in 2018. Disasters such as these lead to a disruption of societies, often cause much damage, lead to loss of lives and pose many challenges for recovery. To make things even worse, disasters are expected to increase in frequency and duration, and the causes of disasters are becoming increasingly diverse and complex. Mainly due to climate change, disasters triggered by extreme natural hazards, such as hurricanes and bushfires, will increasingly strike societies. But also human-induced disasters, such as technological disasters and ecological harms produced by an unsustainable use and exploitation of natural resources, are repeatedly threatening societies. Although these different kinds of disasters seem rather distinct, a shared characteristic of most of them is that they result from the interactions between people and their natural environment. To illustrate, natural disasters, such as hurricanes and earthquakes, are directly caused by the forces of nature. Yet, human or social factors, such as the socio-economic vulnerability of communities and the often disorganized governance of disasters, can also be blamed for influencing and exacerbating the impact of disasters. In this regard, the understanding has been growing that disasters are created by humans - or: 'socially created' - instead of 'acts of God or nature'. In parallel, a shift can be observed in disaster studies. Similar to the shift in governance debates from governing to governance, disaster studies show a development from disaster management to disaster governance. This implies a shift from top-down steering by central governments and a focus on short-term solutions and emergency management, towards the multi-actor sharing of governance roles and longer-term post-disaster transitions. This PhD research focuses on the governance of disasters, because governance can be part of both the cause and solution of disasters. Moreover, it delves into those disasters that occur within and manifest the interface between human actions and natural processes. The research builds on a social-ecological systems perspective to grasp in an integral way the different processes, realities and relevant scales of interaction between natural and social processes shaping societies. Despite the destructive character of disasters, many post-disaster societies express the wish to 'rebuild-back-better'. From this perspective, post-disaster societies often show many bottom-up initiatives to capitalize the momentum for recovering towards a better system. As such, the aftermath of a disaster provides an opportunity to develop towards more resilient and sustainable societies. Nevertheless, post-disaster learning processes rarely result in widespread improvements of governance systems and the urge to go 'back to normal' is often privileged at the expense of the improvement of governance systems to better deal with the dynamics and complexities posed by nature and humans. Why do societies hardly learn from disasters? What explains the societal frustration between different groups of actors in society, often leading to distrust between public, private and civil society institutions? And how can adequate governance systems be created for facilitating post-disaster recovery processes and transitions towards enhanced societal resilience and sustainability? This research contributes to the question what the role is of governance in steering transitions towards more resilient and sustainable social-ecological systems in the face of disasters. It aims to enrich the understanding of disasters and to provide insights in the role of governance and its interaction with natural and socio-institutional processes. A qualitative case-study research of three disasters Based on a qualitative international case-study research of three places in the face of disasters, this research analyzes the ways in which governance can stimulate and enable post-disaster transitions. Based on 89 in-depth interviews, participant observation and document analysis in the three different cases, insights are obtained that contribute to a better understanding of disaster governance. First, the case-study of Christchurch, New Zealand, after the earthquakes in 2011 and 2012 is presented in chapters 2 and 3. Chapter 2 highlights the value of using a social-ecological systems perspective to better understand disasters and their governance. Moreover, the case-study of Christchurch shows that disasters impact societies in a non-homogeneous way, although the governance response is often based on a homogeneous approach. As a consequence, mismatches can be observed between the needs and wishes of impacted people and the focus of the government. Chapter 3 analyzes an essential condition for resilience: learning. In the aftermath of the earthquakes in Christchurch, there were many bottom-up initiatives by civil society organizations to use the disaster as an opportunity to 'build-back-better', nurturing the ground for learning processes. Signs of post-disaster learning could also be observed amongst public and private institutions. However, these learning processes did not lead to widespread societal learning, adaptation and transformation, which hindered the resilience ambition of the city. In fact, learning stayed rather isolated and not bridged between different levels of the multi-level governance system. Second, the case-study of Chiloé, Chile, in the face of the Infectious Salmon Anemia (ISA) disaster is studied in chapter 4. Chiloé, an island in southern Chile, which locates a large industry of salmon production, was impacted by the virus Infectious Salmon Anemia (ISA) in 2007. The ISA disaster disrupted the local society and caused severe social, economic and environmental problems. The case-study of Chiloé analyses how resilience of some subsystems can be so rigid and inflexible that it hinders the resilience of other parts and the sustainability of wider systems. As such, this chapter explores the role of governance in interaction with socio-natural processes and found that the strong biotechnological resilience of the salmon industry, on the one hand, hinders changes aiming for resilience of the wider system, on the other hand. Third, chapter 5 presents the case-study of the earthquakes caused by gas extraction in the province of Groningen, the Netherlands. This case-study embodies the social creation of disasters in a very direct way by exploring social processes that lead to a widespread human-induced disaster. Like the first two case-studies, this case highlights the value of a social-ecological systems perspective for understanding the socio-economic vulnerabilities, political-institutional factors, technological and natural dimensions that in their combination lead to the earthquakes and related problems. The case-study focuses on governance processes that aim to increase societal resilience and sustainability, but in reality seem to hinder these ambitions due to the too rigid entanglement of public-private institutional structures, the nature of the disaster and societal distrust. Chapter 6 discusses the findings of the three cases in an integral way through the lenses of multi-level governance for encouraging post-disaster transitions. Despite the frustration and decreasing trust amongst many actors in society, various socially innovative governance practices and processes can be observed in all three cases. Yet, the lack of inclusive planning, risk awareness, risk acceptance and disaster politics seem to hinder the institutional embedding of learning processes to allow wider societal transitions. This PhD research shows that disasters have the power to uncover inconvenient realities, on the one hand. These realities often contribute to the unfolding of the disaster in the first place. On the other hand, disasters also have the power to trigger chances for resilience and sustainability. However, post-disaster learning processes do only rarely lead to broad societal transitions. Only when resilience refers to learning, adaptation and transformation, and encourages in an integral way the social, economic, and natural pillars of sustainability, post-disaster transitions towards enhanced resilience and sustainability can be enabled. The heterogeneity of disasters Disasters have the potential to shake societies and their governance systems not only temporarily, but often for years afterwards as well. It is therefore highly important to create governance processes that are both adequate to meet the needs of society in the first phases of emergency response and to also facilitate multi-actor decision-making processes about longer-term shared ambitions. Recovery processes after disasters, nevertheless, can often be characterized by frustration and a growing distrust amongst different actors in society. People often call for a more socially inclusive process as they want to have their say about the future of their places, want to get recognition for the problems they face and tend to organize themselves in all sorts of initiatives. However, people often feel discouraged in their participatory wishes by the governance approaches pursued by governments and/or private institutions. These diverging views in post-disaster contexts can be explained by the heteroge
Source: Lirias
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2927438374
Cites:
Cited by: 4
Related to: 9