Work

International cooperation by (European) security and intelligence services: reviewing the creation of a joint database in light of data protection guarantees

Year: 2019
Type: article
Abstract: Increasing multinational cooperation between intelligence and security services, including the establishment of a joint database on (alleged) jihadists, raises legal concerns over the protection of personal data, in particular with respect to the allocation of responsibility among participating states, the geographic scope of fundamental data protection norms, and the applicable law. It is argued that states participating in multinational cooperative efforts may share responsibility, eg in relation to a shared database. However, for reasons of proximity, the host state of the server has heightened duties of care. It is also argued that where a participating state, in particular the host state, exercises virtual control (jurisdiction) over an individual person’s data, such a state has data protection obligations towards that person, regardless of the latter’s location. Participating states, and again in particular the host state, are under an obligation to put in place adequate control systems, including with a view to preventing the transfer of data that have been gathered by states in breach of data protection guarantees. If systemic failures in the multilateral system are identified, states are barred from transferring data to the system, unless they can obtain credible guarantees that data will be adequately protected. General principles of data protection law, derived from case law as well as general or sector-specific regulations, govern the processing and transfer of data in the context of multinational intelligence cooperation, including the management of a joint database. There is no reason not to apply them in the context of national security. National intelligence and security services are stepping up their cooperation to address national security threats, in particular terrorism. Given the sensitivity of national security, such cooperation will normally occur on the basis of legally non-binding, informal arrangements rather than ‘hard’ treaties.1 Under these arrangements, states scale up the exchange of data concerning persons of interest. Most notably, the Counter Terrorism Group (CTG), which consists of the EU Member States plus Norway and Switzerland,2 has activated a database containing personal data of (alleged) jihadists travelling to, or returning from particular conflict areas. The database is (near) real-time available to all CTG participating services. In 2017, an operational platform was formally opened, which allows for more detailed multilateral consultations. This operational platform is also available to all CTG participating services.3 This database is fed by all participating states,4 but its server is based on the territory of just one of them, in The Netherlands, hosted by the AIVD, the Dutch General Intelligence and Security Service.5 In terms of set-up, the database somewhat resembles the database established by European police services and managed by Europol.6 These developments raise acute questions as to the adequate protection of data by multiple cooperating states, in particular as to the locus of responsibility in case of breach and the required level of data protection. In essence, four legal questions arise: (1) What form of responsibility for data breaches does the non-binding informal cooperation envisaged by the security services yield?; (2) Do the individuals whose data are processed fall within the jurisdiction of the participating states, ie do these states have human rights obligations vis-à-vis the individuals concerned, who may well happen to be outside the territory?; (3) Under what circumstances is the responsibility of the database manager engaged when he processes deficient data from participating states, and vice versa, under what circumstances is the responsibility of a state engaged when it transfers data to a deficient international database?; (4) What substantive guarantees as to the level of data protection and the management of the database need to be provided, and in particular from what legal regime are they to be drawn (the legal regime of the server’s host state, an international legal regime …)? This article, which is based on an expert opinion of the authors to the Dutch Review Committee on the Intelligence and Security Services (CTIVD),7 is relevant for cooperation among all security and intelligence services. Its emphasis, however, lies on the exchange of data between European states, defined here as states that are Contracting Parties to the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), or at least the exchange of data accompanied by the creation of a centralized database of which the server is located on the territory of an ECHR Contracting Party. The geographical limitation to ECHR Contracting Parties allows us to review the envisaged cooperation in light of the jurisdictional and substantive guarantees provided by the ECHR, as notably developed by the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). The authors have also taken into account the extensive legislation and case law of the European Union (EU) on data protection in order to develop an appropriate normative framework. The authors bear in mind that according to the Treaty on European Union (TEU), EU law does not govern national security matters as such.8 Accordingly, from a it does not apply to the envisaged of cooperation between intelligence and security services. national security is not from the scope of the of Rights of the European Union (the including by the European Court of based on the the legal developments at the level of the EU may for the cooperative arrangements with which are The cooperation between EU police services, accompanied by the creation of the database managed by EU on the basis of an EU which for extensive data protection can be in is based on applicable international law and law, in particular with respect to questions of jurisdiction and by sector-specific from and data protection law. This the of the The the of responsibility on the basis of non-binding, cooperation between intelligence and security services. The the individuals whose data are the database fall within the jurisdiction of of the participating The in the context of data what responsibility is engaged for breaches to data and responsibility are with in the and in the context of data The data protection what substantive data apply in the context of the establishment of the database. are in the to national security are Accordingly, states are to share data such at least on the basis of legal However, such need not to informal arrangements that are not legally such as or of they address that are to be returning for such international cooperation may well be in of the law, states have into informal cooperative arrangements of international legal It is that national intelligence and security services to cooperation the exchange of data, including the establishment of on the basis of informal cooperative This informal multilateral cooperation the responsibility for data is who obligations to an adequate level of data and who is in case of Under law, ECHR Contracting Parties are not barred from international This exchange intelligence in the context of national relevant case law that states are from up an international cooperative in such a that individual rights are In order to adequately human the for a level of protection that is at least to the level of protection normally by the This is as the based on the of the to an international or adequate the participating states or states which obligations under the of the will not be This does not apply when the state does more than just and exercises The was developed in the context of the transfer of to an (the This is a international legal person, which may responsibility in its However, the of the of international cooperation with the of adequate rights guarantees to of international This the informal as envisaged by intelligence and security services, which does not a legal with a If that is and the relevant one or more state as data or in particular the host state of the and the an adequate level of data the host state, as a or of the international cooperative and its This in the It may just happen that the cooperative does not for adequate data protection guarantees which the host state may it to the In the of a allocation of responsibility in a and in the of on data protection it will be on the host state to adequate guarantees. This is from the of a state for at the national level taken by an international or of a state in respect of of of an international in the envisaged informal international cooperation between intelligence and security services, is no international with the responsibility to In a of informal cooperation which does not a legal person, it that the participating states are for the processing of data and the management of the envisaged as they have a shared obligation to an adequate level of data obligation which fall on the international In case of data these states may share responsibility with obligations to shared responsibility is in international are relevant in international case law that of state to a particular as a case the Court of can be In the Court in a on that obligations based on a the territory of an to which also the and was one of the participating states, the Court that it a of a breach by of the obligations under the the international in the that and the joint obligations to security and order on the of the on the basis of a with respect to the and of the in that a of participating states to a This that multiple states can have obligations with respect to a which is located on the territory of just one the database which is the of or will be located on the territory of one In the the between the participating states the relevant shared In informal on cooperation between intelligence and security services may well on particular notably data protection. In however, international obligations of the participating states will as in particular international or human rights obligations to data protection. international cooperation, participating states are under a joint obligation to the of the envisaged data processing with human rights a of the data protection guarantees in an international legal but the general principles of data protection applicable the data protection participating states may in share responsibility for breaches in the context of a shared database. However, the host state, ie the state on whose territory the server of the database is may have a heightened responsibility, in particular a of care. of the of the or in the of the of the cooperative that the host state will develop and the database to be a in security and intelligence the host state can in control and over the processing of data than states and it will also have a more extensive data responsibility, that European are more to the intelligence and security services of the host state rather than the services of more participating states as data or data which are by data law. The heightened responsibility of the host state however, not that the participating states have no responsibility, of a responsibility may be In international law, it is not what the establishment of shared responsibility in particular the obligation of of the as well as the obligation to for by these or that be and to the respect to the obligation to the of joint and responsibility, or as it is in law, be In the it has been argued that to informal international cooperation arrangements between national intelligence and security services, participating states may in share responsibility for data breaches with the establishment of a joint database. However, under human rights such as the ECHR, a responsibility can be it is required that the individuals by a data fall within the jurisdiction of that This jurisdictional is an as it the of responsibility for at least under the ECHR a state breach an obligation which it does not in the into the of jurisdiction in a which has with multiple states to the of states human rights obligations to an it is an of the geographical or of human rights The of data exchange The has not the and to what data located in a joint or at least the individuals to the data fall within a However, as to the jurisdictional scope of the to data protection can be in case law on the of the This case law as the relevant jurisdictional as a state exercises control over an the will fall within the The has the of control rather as control over or control on the basis of the of a personal control to which a state control over an regardless of as the jurisdictional It is that jurisdiction is not with responsibility under the ECHR responsibility will be engaged in case the state has an ie a breach of an international obligation that can be to the a particular may fall within a but the responsibility may not be engaged no has been versa, a may not fall within a the which for a of be the of breaches to the This is under the of the of state responsibility, breach and for a of state responsibility, regardless of under the of international and human rights law, in particular the ECHR, an jurisdictional which is This may not to be as it allows states to for breaches that are to the from the of the ECHR as well as the case law of the it will also be in the In it is to what persons by data breaches which occur the data has been to the database fall within the jurisdiction of the participating states eg as a of data management and processing or is between the host state, ie the participating state the database on a server located on its and the participating This does not address the the responsibility of the participating states be engaged in respect of This is with in the in the context of data which on the one participating states, in particular the host state, be for data breaches by just one of them, and on the states be for transferring data to a deficient database managed by all states, in particular by the host Do persons whose data is in the database fall within the jurisdiction of the host case law that breaches of the to which occur on a fall within that regardless of the or of the persons to the data This that breaches which to data on a server located on the territory of the host state, in fall within the latter’s a of the that state no obligation under ie the to to persons of are outside its territory in respect of between them which that This that states which and a joint including the host state, have no obligations under ECHR towards persons who are not on their such a of the jurisdictional control by the is The to have in an the in respect of the of it not under of the that the of was place outside the The the that the matters of fall within the jurisdictional of the one or of the or is is as an which fall within the It is persons whose data are processed in a database fall within the jurisdiction of the host state, the or its responsibility for breaches by transferring or with the In that the breaches to fall within the jurisdiction of the host state, but responsibility is shared with however, the host state have a heightened responsibility, a of in light of its to the database and the it is that personal data in the or at least persons to these fall within the jurisdiction of the host state, it is that they also fall within the jurisdiction of the participating states, the responsibility for the and breaches its may in be shared the Under the of jurisdiction will not normally be However, the relevant to jurisdiction may also be a based on control by state as a state with respect to data in the the state has a relevant on the persons to the data The jurisdictional one of does the state have control over and an on the data and the persons to they It will on the of the database states than the host state in as the management of the database has been to the host state, it is that the relevant persons will fall within the jurisdiction of the participating In the it was argued in data breaches in the context of the management of the joint database to shared responsibility of the participating states, it was that the host state may have a heightened In the it was that persons by data breaches to the database do as a of fall within the human rights jurisdiction of the participating states the host on the jurisdictional and it is relevant persons may well fall within the jurisdiction of the host state, and to a of participating This on the somewhat of data It is what obligations the participating states, or least for the database have in respect of data from individual states, and vice versa, what obligations individual states have in respect of data to the database. The responsibility for data to the the participating states in more the host state, for data breaches by just one state, which the data the database that no breaches The individual responsibility for database the and a participating state is for transferring data to a deficient international ie a database which does not adequate data protection guarantees. have breaches which occur the also place the participating state may a and the data the database. The the persons to the data are within the jurisdiction of the participating states, in particular of the host into responsibility the is participating responsibility is engaged for the deficient of the data by one participating a jurisdictional it can be that the relevant persons do in not fall within the jurisdiction of the participating states than the state transferring the data, at least not under the of the participating states not control the of the Under a more personal of which the normative or of a participating state with a person, eg the transfer of data to on the basis of an international jurisdiction may be but it is the jurisdiction to be however, it is not the responsibility of the participating states, and in particular of the host state, will be The law of responsibility does not as such the with which are in the not the law of state responsibility relevant to ECHR of an intelligence regime the case between the and the on the that under in case does not in the which in occur within the and was not to that under international the responsibility of a state, eg the host state, may be engaged for data, an that was not by the in it may and breaches by states in of the of law, however, such responsibility to breaches of norms, such as the of protection breaches do not to the level of such the Court of has that also breaches of obligations the of and the for states to in the of a by such obligations are obligations in which the international has an interest. It be argued that data protection obligations are such but for the to be the breach has to be This a which may be to be a responsibility be engaged on these they have to put in place control that data from the system, or at least from to processing and to services. obligations on the host state of the database. In from a jurisdiction as the in a state may be in the to as as it and and the in Contracting States to an to the of or the of from they their obligations under the The responsibility for data the responsibility of in with breaches by one participating This the of the responsibility of one state in with breaches by it a individual responsibility for transferring data to an international database which does not adequate data protection guarantees. It may when a state has data to an international database managed by the host state, the does not bear responsibility for breaches by the the does no control the data the transfer of it to be in the management of the as in the The has not in the context of data protection. However, it has a in the and It that the responsibility of a Contracting is engaged in case it or an individual to state, including a where it is that he will be to a ECHR Under responsibility and under the ECHR the state of the or where or or are or where of the to a may under the in the of data a responsibility under the ECHR is engaged when it is that the international database to which it transfers data is deficient from a data protection Under the general law of state responsibility to ECHR however, it is in such a responsibility be to the transferring state, an in of responsibility can be If the transferring responsibility be engaged on the basis of to or to such responsibility it is on that state to guarantees from that no data breaches will occur In be of the of guarantees concerning adequate data protection from states to which data are and the by European in In case the guarantees are a in light of the circumstances and the available at the of the transferring state be for breaches by the responsibility at is based on it is not The in the individual responsibility for database to state transferring data to This participating states, but also states on the basis of an informal with the participating states, are to data the It emphasis, however, that the responsibility of the participating states in with breaches at the level of the system may also be more engaged on the basis of the of systemic in the the participating states have up the in the of a international legal the all of them may shared responsibility for systemic the however, it has been in light of the database will be managed in responsibility may with the host This that may be a for the of responsibility of the participating states, as in that states are for in relation the establishment of a a to the applicable the protection of data to and on that database. data transfer to, and management of the database a of states, it is that applicable not be drawn from one they be based on general principles of data protection law, or in national law. The general for data protection law is in ECHR, in Convention of the of and in and EU on such as the General the on the protection of personal data processed in the context of law and or the do not apply to the of national security services, EU law does not apply to national security. The general in respect of data protection in ECHR and and have been and developed in extensive case law of the and the a detailed of case law outside the scope of article, of the can be In the context of the ECHR, the has and its on in the by the and case and the Rights and which to the between fundamental rights and national security, including in an These also that the over national security based on the and does not to its by the national security in of the The of states that national security the responsibility of Member a in the case of of The is to and of on and (the a by the of to a of an that it data to the Security and Intelligence of a Member within the scope of Union law and of the the case law, general principles of data protection law can be derived which relevant in the context of national security, and also for multilateral data These which with what is as as developed within the of the for and for (1) data processing be to a and not than limitation and data (2) the and security of the data be (3) rights of data be (4) where it concerns the for the as well as the also at such as the of the data or and the of that are to an adequate system of In the the these principles in a national security the the of which may to an a of the of to have their a on the of the to be for and the data the to be taken when the data to and the circumstances in which data may or be or to the of the the need for for the of and the provided for by national It is to that these from an on the sector-specific data protection do not apply to national security they the principles at a more detailed This is at the EU where in not the was but also to and In these are of and on security and by are for sector-specific such as when and to a a can that data national security will be by what is as relevant in general and in the context of The of the in to national a of such an This the joint database that is the of the are EU Member States or European with it is that in case of will apply a or will just apply taken from (EU) an also be with the was again in which to the EU for reasons of national security, may be but an to be in a This a of on states, which will have to on of data or be in national security on the can be derived from the Rights where the an EU on data for reasons including on the of the data the of the of data joint database the state from responsibility in respect from the national that govern the of a participating in the database not the by the in a breach that to be data security as well as case law place on and processing in the context of national security and is not with fundamental rights case law has developed the need for the EU in respect of data protection in exchange with the principles of for the sector-specific it is to that in respect of the of multilateral cooperation by intelligence be the in order to a system of in place breach of the principles and be in It is of case law of the may in the context of data to states or international In the case of a joint database hosted in the under the control of the Dutch of Dutch of the at a with national law and can be in to the European in the Netherlands, national security is not of the legal is it of the applicable to the Intelligence and Security Services 2017, for data and data processing by the intelligence and security This does not on a joint database. However, in a the Dutch Review Committee on the Intelligence and Security Services has it that to the joint database do fall within its The has the on with national well as European and principles on such as data Increasing multinational cooperation between intelligence and security services, including the establishment of a joint database on (alleged) jihadists, raises legal concerns over the protection of personal data, in particular with respect to the allocation of responsibility among participating states, the geographic scope of fundamental data protection norms, and the applicable law. In it has been argued that states participating in multinational cooperative efforts may share responsibility, eg in relation to a shared but for reasons of proximity, the host state of the server has heightened duties of care. It has also been argued that where a participating state, in particular the host state, exercises virtual control (jurisdiction) over an individual person’s data, such a state has data protection obligations towards that person, regardless of the latter’s location. Participating states, as in particular the host state, are under an obligation to put in place adequate control systems, including with a view to preventing the transfer of data that have been gathered by state in breach of data protection guarantees. If systemic failures in the multilateral system are identified, states are barred from transferring data to the system, unless they can obtain credible guarantees that data will be adequately protected. General principles of data protection law, derived from case law as well as general or sector-specific regulations, govern the processing and transfer of data in the context of multinational intelligence cooperation, including the management of a joint database. There is no reason not to apply them in the context of national security. has been by the European under the and the Dutch for under the on an opinion in to the of Dutch intelligence
Language: English
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $4,850
OpenAlex ID: W2929397190
FWCI: 12.68
Cites: 1
Cited by: 29
Related to: 10