The chemistry of fine-grained terrigenous sediments reveals a chemically evolved Paleoarchean emerged crust
Year: 2019
Type: article
Source: Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
Authors: Nicolas D. Greber, Nicolas Dauphas
Institutions: University of Geneva, University of Chicago
Language: English
Subfield: Geochemistry and Petrology
Field: Earth and Planetary Sciences
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
Awards: Temporal coupling of environmental change, volcanism and evolution in the geological past through high-precision geochronology, OBJECTIVES:IN SEPTEMBER 2016 NASA WILL LAUNCH A ROCKET TO SEND THE OSIRIS-REX SPACECRAFT ON A RENDEZ VOUS MISSION TO B-TYPE ASTEROID 101955 BENNU FOR SAMPLING ITS SURFACE. MUCH OF THE DISCUSSION ON THESE ROCKS WILL UNDOUBTEDLY INVOLVE UNDERSTANDING THEIR IRRADIATION HISTORY.FOR HOW LONG WERE THE ROCKS EXPOSED TO GALACTIC COSMIC RAYS? AT WHAT DEPTH WERE THE ROCKS BURIED WHEN THEY WERE EXPOSED TO THOSE COSMIC RAYS? DID SUCH IRRADIATION AFFECT THE CHEMICAL AND ISOTOPIC COMPOSITIONS OF THE ROCKS AND IF YES CAN SUCH EFFECTS BE CORRECTED FOR? HOW ARE COSMOGENIC EFFECTS AFFECTED BY THE TARGET COMPOSITION AND ITS WATER CONTENT? THE BEST TRACERS OF THOSE EFFECTS ARE ISOTOPES WITH LARGE CAPTURE CROSS SECTIONS AND RESONANCE INTEGRALS FOR THERMAL AND EPITHERMAL NEUTRONS. LANTHANIDES (REES) POSSESS MANY ISOTOPES WITH LARGE THERMAL NEUTRON CROSS SECTIONS AND RESONANCE INTEGRALS. THEY HAVE PROVEN TO BE EXTREMELY USEFUL FOR UNDERSTANDING THE COSMIC RAY EXPOSURE HISTORY OF LUNAR ROCKS AND METEORITES. GIVEN THAT OSIRIS-REX WILL RECOVER SURFACE ASTEROIDAL SAMPLES CONSIDERATION OF THOSE EFFECTS WILL BE IMPORTANT.THERE IS LITTLE EXPERTISE IN THE USA ON CALCULATION OF NEUTRON CAPTURE EFFECTS IN REES AND MUCH OF THE FOCUS IN REE ISOTOPE MEASUREMENTS HAS BEEN IN THE ANALYSIS OF SM AND ND FOR GEOCHRONOLOGIC APPLICATIONS. THE PROPOSED WORK WILL ALLOW US TO (1) CONTINUE DEVELOPING AND TESTING CHROBOT A NEW AUTOMATED CHROMATOGRAPHY SYSTEM FOR PURIFYING REES TO MEASURE NEUTRON CAPTURE EFFECTS (2) DOCUMENT COSMOGENIC EFFECTS FOR REES IN TARGETS OF CARBONACEOUS CHONDRITE COMPOSITIONS FOR WHICH ALMOST NO DATA IS AVAILABLE AND (3) DEVELOP THE SCIENTIFIC CONTEXT FOR INTERPRETING THOSE VARIATIONS BY RUNNING SIMULATIONS OF NEUTRON CAPTURE EFFECTS IN TARGET COMPOSITIONS REPRESENTATIVE OF THE MATERIALS THAT OSIRIS-REX MAY ENCOUNTER.METHODOLOGY:OVER THE PAST 2 YEARS WE HAVE DEVELOPED AN ALL-TEFLON PNEUMATIC CHROMATOGRAPHY SYSTEM TO SEPARATE REES FROM ONE ANOTHER. THE MOTIVATIONS FOR DEVELOPING THIS SYSTEM ARE TWO-FOLD: (1) IT ALLOWS US TO ISOLATE ELEMENTS THAT ARE NOTORIOUSLY DIFFICULT TO SEPARATE FROM ONE ANOTHER BY RUNNING LONGER COLUMNS UNDER CONTROLLED TEMPERATURE CONDITIONS YIELDING BETTER CHROMATOGRAPHIC SEPARATIONS AND (2) IT ALLOWS US TO ACHIEVE BETTER SEPARATIONS IN A COMPUTER CONTROLLED PROCEDURE USING LESS COLUMN PASSES THUS MINIMIZING THE RISK OF SAMPLE LOSS CONTAMINATION AND MISHANDLING. MORE ELEMENTS CAN BE SEPARATED IN A SINGLE COLUMN PASS MAKING OPTIMUM USE OF THE SAMPLES.THE SYSTEM IS ESTABLISHED AND THE NEXT 3 YEARS WILL BE DEVOTED TO ASSESSING ITS ROUTINE OPERATION TO SEPARATE REES FOR STUDY OF NEUTRONCAPTURE EFFECTS. SCIENTIFICALLY WE WILL ADDRESS THE QUESTION OF HOW DO DIFFERENT TARGET MATERIALS AND SECONDARY ENERGY SPECTRA AFFECT THE ISOTOPIC COMPOSITIONS OF THE REES? THIS WILL BE INVESTIGATED BY (1) COMBINING ISOTOPIC ANALYSES OF ELEMENTS THAT HAVE DIFFERENT SENSITIVITIES TO DIFFERENT NEUTRON ENERGIES AND (2) STUDYING THOSE EFFECTS IN CARBONACEOUS CHONDRITES TAKEN AS PROXIES FOR BENNU SAMPLES. THOSE MEASUREMENTS WILL BE COMBINED WITH ONGOING SIMULATIONS OF NEUTRON CAPTURE EFFECTS IN AN INVERSION CALCULATION TO DERIVE THE SECONDARY NEUTRON ENERGY SPECTRUM. THE CALCULATIONS WILL INVESTIGATE HOW TARGET COMPOSITIONS (E.G. VARIABLE WATER CONTENTS) AFFECT COSMOGENIC EFFECTS FOR THE REES.RELEVANCE:THIS STUDY WILL STRENGTHEN THE EXPERTISE OF A US LAB IN THE MEASUREMENTS AND INTERPRETATION OF COSMOGENIC NEUTRON CAPTURE EFFECTS IN PLANETARY SURFACES OF CARBONACEOUS CHONDRITE COMPOSITIONS A KEY ASPECT OF THE STUDY OF THE OSIRIS-REX MISSION. IT IS THUS HIGHLY RELEVANT TO NASA'S STRATEGIC OBJECTIVES (SOLICITATION NNH16ZDA001N-LARS) WHICH INCLUDE "DEVELOPMENT OF LABORATORY INSTRUMENTATION AND/OR ADVANCED TECHNIQUES REQUIRED FOR THE ANALYSIS OF RETURNED SAMPLES" (DOCUMENT C18 OF THE SOLICITATION PAGE C.18-1)., OBJECTIVES: IF LIFE EVER EMERGED ON MARS IT MIGHT HAVE BEEN SIMILAR TO CHEMOTROPHIC BACTERIA WHICH CREATE MINERAL DEPOSITS IN KINETICALLY UNFAVORABLE CONDITIONS FOR THE EQUIVALENT ABIOTIC REACTIONS. HEMATITE-JAROSITE DEPOSITS AT MERIDIANI PLANUM REQUIRE THAT FERROUS FE FROM WEATHERING OF MARTIAN BASALT WAS OXIDIZED IN ACIDIC CONDITIONS (PH 2-4). AT SUCH LOW PH FE OXIDATION BY O2 IS VERY SLOW AND THE FORMATION OF SIMILAR DEPOSITS ON EARTH IS USUALLY MEDIATED BY BACTERIA. TIME LIMITS FOR FE OXIDATION ON MARS ARE IMPOSED BY THE LIFETIME OF STANDING WATER BODIES AND IF ABIOTIC FE OXIDATION RATES IN ACID WATERS ARE FOUND TO BE INADEQUATE TO ACCOUNT FOR HEMATITEJAROSITE DEPOSITS THIS COULD MAKE A COMPELLING CASE THAT BIOLOGY PLAYED A ROLE IN ACCELERATING OXIDATION. HOWEVER FE OXIDATION CAN ALSO BE DRIVEN BY UV PHOTONS. EARLIER STUDIES SUGGEST THIS MAY BE A VIABLE PATHWAY FOR HEMATITE-JAROSITE FORMATION BUT THE KINETICS ARE INADEQUATELY CHARACTERIZED IN THE CHEMICAL AND RADIATIVE ENVIRONMENT OF MERIDIANI PLANUM. THE DEPENDENCE OF THE QUANTUM YIELD (ATOMS OXIDIZED PER PHOTON ABSORBED) ON FE SPECIATION AND UV WAVELENGTH AND HAS NOT BEEN DETERMINED WHICH LIMITS EXTRAPOLATION OF EXPERIMENTAL PHOTO-OXIDATION RATES TO ACIDIC WATERS UNDER MARTIAN SURFACE CONDITIONS. CHARACTERIZING PHOTO-OXIDATION RATES ON MARS IS NECESSARY IN ASSESSING WHETHER IRON OXIDATION COULD HAVE BEEN AN ENERGY SOURCE FOR LIFE AT MERIDIANI PLANUM. WE WILL CONDUCT NEW PHOTO-OXIDATION EXPERIMENTS TO DEFINE THE QUANTUM YIELD AS A FUNCTION OF WAVELENGTH AND FE SPECIATION AND DETERMINE RATES OF OXIDATION UNDER A UV SPECTRUM RELEVANT TO THE INCIDENT RADIATION AT THE MARTIAN SURFACE. OUR EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS WILL FORM THE BASIS OF THE HOLISTIC GEOCHEMICAL MODELS THAT WE WILL BUILD TO DETERMINE THE RELATIVE EFFICIENCY OF COMPETING BIOTIC AND ABIOTIC PATHWAYS TO FE OXIDATION IN ACID WATERS., OBJECTIVES:THE ORIGIN OF ALL SOLAR SYSTEM MATERIALS CAN BE TRACED BACK TO SMALL DUST GRAINS THAT WERE PRESENT IN THE SOLAR PROTOPLANETARY DISK 4.567 BILLION YEARS AGO. THESE DUST GRAINS THEN AGGLOMERATED AND WERE INCORPORATED IN THE MIX OF MATERIALS THAT MADE THE TERRESTRIAL PLANETS. THE ELEMENTS AVAILABLE IN A PLANET THUS DEPEND ON THE NATURE AND PROCESSING OF DUST DURING THE EARLIEST STAGES OF THE EVOLUTION OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM. THE CHEMICAL COMPOSITION OF A PLANET IS AN IMPORTANT PARAMETER THAT DETERMINES ITS GEOLOGICAL GEODYNAMIC AND BIOLOGICAL EVOLUTION BY CONTROLLING HOW MUCH HEAT-PRODUCING ELEMENTS ARE AVAILABLE TO POWER PLANETARY DIFFERENTIATION THE NATURE OF THE MINERALS PRESENT AND HOW MUCH NUTRIENTS ARE AVAILABLE TO SUSTAIN LIFE. SOME METEORITES HAVE REMAINED LARGELY UNDISTURBED SINCE THEIR FORMATION AND AS SUCH THEY PROVIDE INSIGHTS INTO THE NEBULAR PROCESSES THAT CONTROLLED THE COMPOSITIONS OF PLANETS. DESPITE SIGNIFICANT PROGRESS IN OUR UNDERSTANDING OF THESE PROCESSES SEVERAL QUESTIONS REMAIN UNANSWERED.1. WHAT IS THE CAUSE OF THE OBSERVED DIVERSITY OF COMPOSITIONS AMONG PLANETARY BODIES?2. TO WHAT EXTENT WERE PRESOLAR ISOTOPIC SIGNATURES HOMOGENIZED DURING SOLAR SYSTEM FORMATION? DID SEVERAL NEBULAR RESERVOIRS COEXIST WITHOUT MIXING?3. CAN WE TIE THE COMPOSITIONS OF PLANETS TO METEORITES?TO ADDRESS THESE OUTSTANDING QUESTIONS WE PROPOSE TO MEASURE THE ISOTOPIC COMPOSITIONS OF REFRACTORY ELEMENTS CA TI AND SELECTED LANTHANIDES (ND ER AND YB) IN REFRACTORY INCLUSIONS AND BULK CHONDRITES.METHODOLOGY:LANTHANIDES ARE A FAMILY OF REFRACTORY ELEMENTS THAT SHARE SIMILAR CHEMICAL PROPERTIES BUT KEY DIFFERENCES IN THEIR BEHAVIORS MAKE THEM INVALUABLE TRACERS OF EVAPORATION/CONDENSATION PROCESSES. MUCH OF THE WORK DONE UNTIL NOW HAS FOCUSED ON THE RELATIVE ABUNDANCES OF THE LANTHANIDES BUT INTERPRETATIONS OF ABUNDANCE PATTERNS ARE OFTEN NON-STRAIGHTFORWARD. BY SYSTEMATICALLY MEASURING THE ISOTOPIC COMPOSITIONS OF CA TI AS WELL AS HIGHLY REFRACTORY ER MODERATELY REFRACTORY ND AND MORE VOLATILE YB IN PLANETARY MATERIALS A QUANTITATIVE UNDERSTANDING OF THE NEBULAR PROCESSES GOVERNING THE FRACTIONATION OF REFRACTORY LITHOPHILE ELEMENTS WILL BE DEVELOPED. NOVEL TECHNIQUES WILL BE USED TO SEPARATE THESE ELEMENTS AND THEIR ISOTOPIC COMPOSITIONS WILL BE ANALYZED BY MULTI-COLLECTOR INDUCTIVELY COUPLED PLASMA MASS SPECTROMETRY.MOST ISOTOPIC VARIATIONS FOLLOW THE LAWS OF MASS-DEPENDENT FRACTIONATION MEANING THAT THEY SCALE AS THE RELATIVE DIFFERENCE IN MASS OF THE ISOTOPES INVOLVED. DEPARTURES FROM THIS RULE ARE CALLED ISOTOPIC ANOMALIES AND STEM FROM INCOMPLETE MIXING OF THE PRODUCTS OF STELLAR NUCLEOSYNTHESIS IN THE SOLAR DISK. IN THIS WORK WE WILL CHARACTERIZE THE MASS-DEPENDENT AND -INDEPENDENT ISOTOPIC COMPOSITIONS OF REFRACTORY INCLUSIONS AND BULK METEORITES. ISOTOPIC ANOMALIES WILL BE ANALYZED TO DOCUMENT THE EXTENT TO WHICH DIFFERENT ELEMENTS OF VARYING REFRACTORINESS WERE FORMED BY DIFFERENT NUCLEOSYNTHETIC PROCESSES AND HOMOGENIZED ISOTOPICALLY IN THE EARLY SOLAR SYSTEM.RELEVANCE:THE OVERARCHING THEME OF THE PROPOSED WORK IS TO MEASURE THE ISOTOPIC COMPOSITION OF SEVERAL REFRACTORY LITHOPHILE ELEMENTS IN THE SOLAR SYSTEM'S EARLIEST CONDENSATES CHONDRITES AND PLANETS TO EVALUATE THE EXTENT TO WHICH NEBULAR RESERVOIRS WERE MIXED AND CHEMICALLY FRACTIONATED BEFORE PLANETS WERE FORMED. IT IS THUS RELEVANT TO NASA'S STRATEGIC OBJECTIVES (SOLICITATION NNH16ZDA001NEW) WHICH INCLUDE "LARGE-SCALE CHEMICAL AND ISOTOPIC FRACTIONATION PROCESSES; CHEMICAL AND PHYSICAL PROCESSING OF GAS DUST AND ICE; FORMATION ACCRETION AND STABILITY OF SOLAR SYSTEM BODIES" (DOCUMENT C2 OF THE SOLICITATION PAGE C.2-1).
OpenAlex ID: W2937193170
