Contribution of constitutional courts to the democratic quality of elections in Sub-Saharan Africa: a comparative case study of Madagascar and Senegal
Year: 2018
Type: article
Abstract: This thesis is the first comparative study on the role of African constitutional courts in elections. Approximately 20 African countries have introduced such courts during the course of the third wave of democratisation. While it is a widespread scholarly assumption that constitutional courts are beneficial for democracy, studies on the actual democratic repercussions of these courts are rare. Moreover, we know little at present about the nature of African constitutional courts and their role in processes of democratisation. This thesis takes specifically the field of electoral disputes as an example by which to examine the influence of constitutional courts on democracy. Elections are a core feature of democracy, and therefore particularly pertinent for studying constitutional courts’ repercussions on it. This approach is furthermore innovative because scholars of electoral integrity have recognised the importance of courts for democratic elections. Yet, theoretical and empirical works that examine this relationship in more detail are currently only pending. To begin to answer the question of how constitutional courts contribute to the democratic quality of elections in African electoral democracies, the constitutional courts of Madagascar and Senegal are examined in a structured, focused comparison. For this purpose, the study develops a novel theoretical framework that captures how constitutional court behaviour is linked, through their functional, ambiguous or dysfunctional interventions, to the democratic quality of elections. As a theoretical innovation, the thesis combines the concept of the “democratic quality of elections” with that of the “electoral cycle” in disentangling how the three democratic qualities of elections – participation, competition and legitimacy – are at stake throughout the six steps of the electoral cycle. For this thesis, an original dataset of 274 constitutional court interventions was compiled during field research stays in Madagascar and in Senegal. The analysis of these interventions was embedded in data from 78 interviews conducted with constitutional court judges, legal experts and politicians, as well as from secondary sources such as legal comments and election observation reports. The analysis revealed that in both countries all three qualities of democratic elections were subject to constraints during the periods of observation. Focusing on the courts’ major decisions, it was observed that both courts responded to the existing constraints on competition and legitimacy with predominantly dysfunctional interventions. The interventions of the Madagascan High Constitutional Court had, however, more serious repercussions on the democratic quality of elections, which was reflected in the 2009 breakdown of the democratic regime. The discussion of the results against the backdrop of prominent theories of court behaviour shows that the appointment rules and practices in place hampered in both countries the emergence of independent constitutional courts. Furthermore, both courts lacked public support and did not strategically build up a support base – which made them more vulnerable to political pressure. Moreover, the study showed that the relationship between the rule of law and elections is inextricable intertwined. However, this inextricability ultimately leads to a stagnating process in which courts impede electoral integrity and whereby contentious elections undermine assertive judicial decision making.
Author: Charlotte Heyl
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: constitutional courts, electoral disputes, electoral cycles, electoral integrity, judicial independence, political pressure on courts, judicial legitimacy, electoral competition, electoral participation, electoral legitimacy, third wave of democratization, Madagascar, Senegal, comparative constitutional law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2944030201
