Year: 2019
Type: letter
Abstract: In the December 2018 issue of the Journal, Jha and colleagues (1) claim that antidepressant withdrawal typically resolves spontaneously over 2-3 weeks.They offer only three references in support.Two of these were case reports that included one and three patients (2, 3).In Pyke (3), the withdrawal reaction resolved in 3 weeks, whereas in the case report by Frost and Lal, withdrawal symptoms lasted between 3 and 23 weeks (2).The third reference, a small cohort study of 20 patients by Fava et al. (4), reported that a withdrawal reaction was observed in nine patients (45% of all patients examined), even though the drugs were tapered at the slowest possible pace.The withdrawal syndrome subsided within 4 weeks in six patients (67% of all patients experiencing withdrawal), whereas in three patients (33% of all patients with withdrawal), serious withdrawal symptoms persisted for several months after discontinuation.Not only did Jha and colleagues select only three studies, representing a total of just 24 patients, but the three studies they present to readers as evidence for their 2-3 weeks claim do not actually support their claim at all.In Frost and Lal (2), the three individual withdrawal reactions described lasted between 3 and 23 weeks, and in Fava et al. (4), withdrawal effects lasted considerably longer than 4 weeks in one-third of patients.Based on this evidence, the conclusion that withdrawal reactions "typically resolve spontaneously over 2-3 weeks" is fallacious and arbitrary.Moreover, two references were merely case reports, which have very little external validity.In our view, it is problematic to quote (or, rather, misquote) such anecdotal evidence to corroborate a controversial claim that should represent the broader antidepressant user population.Although there undoubtedly is a need for more research on this important issue, systematic reviews of the existing literature conclude that withdrawal is common, is often severe, and frequently lasts much longer than merely 2-3 weeks, with and without tapering (5, 6).
Source: American Journal of Psychiatry
Authors: Giovanni A. Fava, Fiammetta Cosci
Language: English
Subfield: Pharmacology (medical)
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2947595819
