Work

Effects of reward and punishment on learning from errors in smokers : bold response and task-based functional connectivity

Year: 2019
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Nicotine dependence is the main cause of preventable mortality and morbidity worldwide. Besides health detriments, nicotine dependence appears associated with impairments in emotional and cognitive processes. Dependent smokers have shown hypersensitivity to reward and hyposensitivity to punishment, along with impairments in learning from errors. The underlying neural mechanisms for the failure to adapt performance following an error, particularly when receiving negative feedback, remain unclear. Smokers were hypothesized to have significantly poorer error learning following monetary punishment, but increased motivation by high reward. Smokers’ impaired learning from punished errors was expected to be associated with hypoactivation in the insula, dorsal anterior cingulate cortex and hippocampal regions. Differences between smokers and controls in task-based functional connectivity were expected between regions that have previously been found to be engaged in feedback-based associative learning tasks. Two versions of a feedback-based spatial associative-learning task were administered to different sets of 30 dependent smokers (abstinent more than 3h) and 30 matched controls. One of the tasks was administered during functional magnetic imaging (fMRI) data collection to 23 smokers and 23 matched controls. Whole-brain conventional blood-oxygen level dependent (BOLD) responses and region-of-interest task-based functional connectivity were analysed. Smokers learned less from small rewards and large punishments than controls. The three-way interaction between feedback magnitude, feedback type (reward, punishment) and group was significant, F(1,48) = 5.288, p = 0.026, ɳ2p = 0.099. In the Avoid Learning from Errors task (AvLFE), neither participant group corrected locations offering reward more often than those offering avoidance of punishment and the interaction between group and feedback condition (reward, avoid punishment) was not significant, F(1,58) = 0.0, p = 0.99, ɳ2p =0.001. None of the hypothesized brain regions showed differences between groups. Smokers showed hyperactivity in the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex during recall and re-encoding epochs. Hyperactivity in the re-encoding period was associated with future error-correction in smokers only. While controls showed higher deactivation of the sensorimotor cortex during high punishment, smokers showed higher deactivation during low punishment. Task-based functional connectivity demonstrated increased connectivity between nucleus accumbens (NAcc) and anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) in smokers. Smokers’ connectivity was increased during both recall of corrected and repeated errors, while controls’ connectivity increased, although less than smokers’, during corrected errors but decreased during repeated errors. The results suggest that smokers have poorer learning from errors when receiving negative feedback. Larger rewards reinforced smokers’ behaviour more than smaller rewards, whereas this effect was not present in controls. Conventional BOLD response analysis supports the notion of impaired error-learning in smokers, increased reward anticipation, and decreased attentional control associated with hyperactivity in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. Smokers exhibited decreased punishment sensitivity which appeared to limit their ability to learn when facing repeated punishment. Task-based functional connectivity analysis supported conventional BOLD response findings of increased reward anticipation in smokers, suggesting that increased reward anticipation facilitated impaired negative-feedback processing and reduced error-learning. The findings support the hypothesis that smokers better respond to positively framed and rewarded anti-smoking programs when compared to those relying on negative feedback or punishment.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2949101234
Cites: 325
Cited by:
Related to: 10