A randomised controlled trial of an Intervention to Improve Compliance with the ARRIVE guidelines (IICARus)
Year: 2019
Type: article
Abstract: The ARRIVE (Animal Research: Reporting of In Vivo Experiments) guidelines are widely endorsed but compliance is limited. We sought to determine whether journal-requested completion of an ARRIVE checklist improves full compliance with the guidelines. In a randomised controlled trial, manuscripts reporting in vivo animal research submitted to PLOS ONE (March–June 2015) were randomly allocated to either requested completion of an ARRIVE checklist or current standard practice. Authors, academic editors, and peer reviewers were blinded to group allocation. Trained reviewers performed outcome adjudication in duplicate by assessing manuscripts against an operationalised version of the ARRIVE guidelines that consists 108 items. Our primary outcome was the between-group differences in the proportion of manuscripts meeting all ARRIVE guideline checklist subitems. We randomised 1689 manuscripts (control: n = 844, intervention: n = 845), of which 1269 were sent for peer review and 762 (control: n = 340; intervention: n = 332) accepted for publication. No manuscript in either group achieved full compliance with the ARRIVE checklist. Details of animal husbandry (ARRIVE subitem 9b) was the only subitem to show improvements in reporting, with the proportion of compliant manuscripts rising from 52.1 to 74.1% ( X 2 = 34.0, df = 1, p = 2.1 × 10 −7 ) in the control and intervention groups, respectively. These results suggest that altering the editorial process to include requests for a completed ARRIVE checklist is not enough to improve compliance with the ARRIVE guidelines. Other approaches, such as more stringent editorial policies or a targeted approach on key quality items, may promote improvements in reporting.
Authors: Kaitlyn Hair, Malcolm Macleod, Emily Sena, David Howells, Philip Bath, Cadi Irvine, Catriona MacCallum, Gavin Morrison, Alejandra Clark, Gina Alvino, Michelle Dohm, Programming and data management, Jing Liao, Chris Sena, Redactions, Rosie Moreland, Design of outcome assessment platform, Fala Cramond, Cadi Irvine, Jing Liao, Gillian L. Currie, Zsanett Bahor, Paula Grill, Alexandra Bannach-Brown, Outcome assessment, Kaitlyn Hair, Daniel-Cosmin Marcu, Sarah Antar, Cadi Irvine, Katrina Blazek, Timm Konold, Monica Dingwall, Victoria Hohendorf, Mona Hosh, Paula Grill, Klara Zsofia Gerlei, Kimberley Elaine Wever, Emily Sena, Victor Jones, Terence J Quinn, Natasha A Karp, Jennifer Freymann, Anthony Shek, Teja Gregorc, Arianna Rinaldi, Privjyot Jheeta, Ahmed Nazzal, David Ewart Henshall, Joanne Storey, Julija Baginskaite, Cilene Lino de Oliveira, Kamil Laban, Emmanuel Charbonney, Savannah A. Lynn, Marco Cascella, Emily Wheater, Daniel Baker, Gillian L. Currie, Ryan Cheyne, Edward Christopher, Paolo Roncon, Evandro Araújo De-Souza, Mahmoud Warda, Sarah Corke, Zeinab Ammar, Leigh O’Connor, Ian M. Devonshire, Reconciliation, Kaitlyn Hair, Daniel-Cosmin Marcu, Sarah Antar, Timm Konold, Monica Dingwall, Emily Sena, Paula Grill, Sarah K. McCann, Data analysis, Jing Liao, Laura J Gray, Ezgi Tanriver Ayder
Institutions: University of Edinburgh, University of Tasmania, University of Nottingham, Public Library of Science, Imperial College London, Animal and Plant Health Agency, Mansoura University, UNSW Sydney, Ministry of Health and Population, University of Veterinary Medicine Hannover, Foundation, Radboud University Medical Center, University of Glasgow, AstraZeneca (United Kingdom), Sapienza University of Rome, GlaxoSmithKline (United Kingdom), European Science Foundation, Utrecht University, University Medical Center Utrecht, Hôpital du Sacré-Cœur de Montréal, University of Southampton, Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro
Language: English
Subfield: Small Animals
Field: Veterinary
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,078
OpenAlex ID: W2949899843
