The OPTIMAL study: A randomized controlled trial and process evaluation of an occupational therapy led self-management support programme for people with multimorbidity in primary care
Year: 2019
Type: dissertation
Study designs: Randomized Controlled Trial, Clinical Trial
Abstract: Background: People with multiple chronic conditions or multimorbidity, are particularly vulnerable with poorer health outcomes, higher health service utilisation and costs.Despite the negative impact of multimorbidity on individuals and the healthcare system a recent updated Cochrane review concluded that there was limited research on interventions for those with multimorbidity.The review concluded that interventions were more likely to be effective if they focused either on risk factors common across co-morbid conditions or on generic outcomes such as daily functioning (S.M. Smith, Wallace, O'Dowd, & Fortin, 2016).The provision of function-oriented interventions appear to be in line with preferences and priorities of those with multimorbidity.Occupational therapy has been proposed as a profession suited to delivering interventions for those with multimorbidity due to the profession's generic focus on functioning.Despite this there is a paucity of high quality occupational therapy interventions for those with multimorbidity.The Medical Research Council's (MRC) Framework (2008) for complex interventions was used to develop and pilot "OPTIMAL" an occupational therapy led selfmanagement programme for those with multimorbidity.The OPTIMAL programme is a six-week group based programme focusing on topics of concern to those with multimorbidity including fatigue management, maintaining mental well-being, physical activity, managing medication and communication strategies.Following on from previous developmental and pilot work, the overall aim of this PhD study was to evaluate the effectiveness of the OPTIMAL programme as per Stage III of the MRC framework (Medical Research Council, 2008). Methods:The study was conducted in HSE primary care teams (PCT) in the Dublin Mid-Leinster region.The approach selected was a pragmatic parallel randomised controlled trial.Participants with multimorbidity were recruited from primary care settings.Primary outcome measures were the EQ-VAS (health related quality of life measure) and Frenchay Activities Index (activity participation).Participants were randomly allocated to the intervention group, to attend the OPTIMAL programme, or to the wait list control group, to receive care as usual.Follow-up data collection took place immediately postintervention.Intention to treat and per protocol analyses using multi-level linear regression models were performed.A concurrent mixed methods process evaluation was also used to understand the functioning and effects of the OPTIMAL programme by examining how the intervention was delivered and received in practice.Quantitative process evaluation data were collected using study team recruitment logs, baseline v participant questionnaires, therapist log/fidelity tool and programme attendance records.Qualitative data were collected using focus groups with intervention participants and semi-structured interviews with the occupational therapists and other health professionals who referred to and delivered the programme.Qualitative data were transcribed verbatim and analysed using thematic analysis.Results: In total 149 participants were recruited across eight HSE primary care team areas.At follow-up, immediately post-intervention there was a significant improvement in health-related quality of life for the intervention group (Adjusted mean difference (MD) in EQ-VAS = 7.86; 95% CI=0.92 to 14.80) in comparison to controls.No significant differences were found between the two groups in frequency of activity participation.Sub-group analyses found a significant difference in favour of the intervention group for participants aged <65 in both health-related quality of life (Adjusted EQ-VAS MD = 13.46;95% CI = 1.48 to 25.45) and frequency of activity participation (Adjusted MD = 5.00; 95% CI = 1.29 to 8.72).Sub-group analyses also found a significant difference for intervention participants with four or more chronic conditions in frequency of activity participation (Adjusted MD = 2.86; 95% CI = 0.31 to 5.41).Process evaluation results highlighted significant difficulties with recruitment and wide variation in referral sources by site with some sites unable to deliver the programme.The group-based nature and goal-setting components of the programme were perceived as being important mechanisms of change.Barriers and facilitators to implementation included managerial and collegial support, low participant numbers, resources and caseload demands.Overall the intervention content and delivery was well received by participants and health professionals, who perceived that the intervention improved participants' activity levels, emotional well-being and self-management skills.Conclusion: This study found that the OPTIMAL programme was effective in improving health related quality of life but not frequency of activity participation at immediate followup.The results of ongoing research (6-month follow-up) will be important in determining the sustainability of these clinical effects over time and on other secondary outcomes.The process evaluation highlighted that the intervention was acceptable to health professionals and participants but enablers and barriers to the routine implementation of the OPTIMAL programme in primary care settings were identified.The study's findings can be used to inform the next phase of the MRC framework, Phase IV i.e. implementation.
Authors: O Toole, Lynn Marie
Language: English
Subfield: Occupational Therapy
Field: Health Professions
Domain: Health Sciences
Keywords: multimorbidity, occupational therapy, self-management support, group intervention, primary care, health-related quality of life, activities and participation, fatigue management, medication management, physical activity, psychological well-being, communication strategies, process evaluation, intervention fidelity, complex interventions, MRC framework, daily functioning, health care utilization, health care costs, patient-centered care
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2957559550
