Clarifying differences between reviews within evidence ecosystems
Year: 2019
Type: editorial
Abstract: This paper builds on a 2012 paper by the same authors which argued that the types and brands of systematic review do not sufficiently differentiate between the many dimensions of different review questions and review methods (Gough et al., Syst Rev 1:28, 2012). The current paper extends this argument by considering the dynamic contexts, or 'evidence ecosystems', within which reviews are undertaken; the fact that these ecosystems are constantly changing; and the relevance of this broader context for understanding 'dimensions of difference' in the unfolding development and refinement of review methods.The concept of an evidence ecosystem is used to consider particular issues within the three key dimensions of difference outlined in the 2012 paper of (1) review aims and approach, (2) structure and components of reviews, and (3) breadth, depth, and 'work done' by reviews.
Source: Systematic Reviews
Authors: David Gough, James Thomas, Sandy Oliver
Institutions: University College London, University of Johannesburg
Language: English
Subfield: Statistics, Probability and Uncertainty
Field: Decision Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: evidence ecosystem, review methodology
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,040
OpenAlex ID: W2961682569
