Work

Who or What Can be a Legal Person?

Year: 2019
Type: book-chapter
Abstract: The chapter assesses the rather popular claim that anything can be endowed with legal personhood. This ‘everything-goes’ view is often supported by examples such as the putative legal personhood of Indian idols and the Whanganui River in New Zealand. The chapter exposes a conflation of two senses of the phrase ‘legal person’, which can refer both to the holders of legal positions (rights and duties) or to the legal positions themselves. This conflation often underlies the everything-goes view, rendering it unsustainable. Instead, one must either have the capacity to act or the capacity for claim-rights in order to qualify as a potential legal person. As rivers can neither act nor hold claim-rights, rivers cannot be legal persons. The Whanganui River arrangement should rather be understood as endowing a collectivity—the Maori and other sentient beings who are dependent on the river—with legal personhood.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W2973925245
FWCI: 5.603
Cites: 200
Cited by: 7
Related to: 10