Work

Feminism, Globalization and Culture: After Beijing

Year: 1997
Type: article
Abstract: In this article, Professor Obiora begins with the premise that the\ncredibility of traditional legal frameworks has eroded, because the law\nremains unable to relieve the oppressions and polarization between cultures,\neven in the wake of global institutional transformations that seem to help the\noppressed, particularly women. Professor Obiora offers the Beijing Platform\nfor Action as a radical new solution for human rights protection, radical in\nthat it is one of the first declaratives to transcend the previous dichotomy of\nissues among women by expressing a commitment to a global framework in\nwhich to address these issues, particularly the feminization ofpoverty. After\na briefdescription of the Platform, the author asks whether it is really possible\nto provide such a global framework, given the inherently cultural and\ncommunitarian nature of feminist issues. In the second section, Professor\nObiora argues that because the Platform for Action is not a legally binding\ninstrument, and because traditional sources of monetary and social support\nmay not be present, particularly in developing countries, alternative\nmechanisms for enforcement of the Platform must be explored As a solution,\nthe author suggests that in order to realize the Bey'ing mandate, women need\nto collaborate and move to mechanisms outside traditional institutions. In the\nthird section of the article, Professor Obiora responds to Aihwa Ong 's article,\nand begins by highlighting Ong's concept offeminist imperialism as a starting\ncontext for a discussion of the role of culture in defining a feminist agenda for\nthe alleviation of women's oppression. Professor Obiora then argues that the\ninternational human rights regime is enhanced by culturally-sensitive\napproaches, as centrality is the framework for existence. Yet, Professor\nObiora questions how to define and validate custom or culture in light of the\ninevitable effect of world economic, political, and cultural forces. Professor\nObiora also questions how to reconcile the validation of cultural practices that\nare seen by Western feminists as oppressive to the women who practice them.\nFinally, in the fourth section, Professor Obiora attempts to integrate the\npreviously raised issues with a discussion of a universalist-relativist\nframework. In doing so, the author suggests that the greatest challenge to\ndeveloping a human rights regime that appeals to all cultures may be to\nnegotiate a productive end for the recognition of difference, balancing the\nbenefits of both universalism and relativism.
Institution: Indiana University
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2993516202
FWCI:
Cites: 2
Cited by: 26
Related to: 10