Work

Rights dialogue where there is disagreement under the Victorian Charter

Year: 2020
Type: preprint
Abstract: The Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities Act 2006 (Vic) was enacted with the purpose of creating an inter-institutional dialogue about rights between the arms of government. The dialogue model was designed to achieve the politically-adjudged correct balance between rights and democracy: sensitivity to rights whilst retaining parliamentary sovereignty. This chapter outlines the dialogue mechanisms employed by the Charter, and explores theoretical perspectives on the types of dialogue that may be generated under dialogue-focused rights instruments. Within this framework, the chapter analyses the dialogue occurring under the Charter by reference to ‘complete cycles of dialogue’ – that is, where rights-based judicial decisions have elicited a response from the executive and parliament, or where non-rights-based judicial decisions have elicited rights-impacting responses from the executive and parliament. The case-studies focus on four inter-institutional interactions that manifest disagreement about rights between the arms of government. Disagreement about rights is inevitable, and is accommodated by the Charter’s dialogue mechanisms. However, the manner in which disagreement is expressed may threaten to undermine the much-vaunted educative effects of inter-institutional rights dialogue. The case-studies demonstrate a tendency toward Kent Roach’s dialogue as coordinate construction and judicial accountability, which in truth promote representative monologues about rights. Dialogue based on the distinct, yet complementary, roles of the arms of government ought to be the goal, but the case-studies often miss this target. The type of dialogue matters, and the arms of government should learn the art of conversation required under the Charter.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3009667126
Cites:
Cited by: 2
Related to: 9