Work

The Role of ‘Autonomy’ in Teaching Expertise

Year: 2017
Type: article
Abstract: For a few decades now, debates around the effects of ‘new public measures’ in education have pointed to how the emphasis on increased accountability and high stakes testing has led to some worrying phenomena—such as narrowing of the curriculum, gaming and teaching to the test (Jacob, 2004; West and Pennell 2005)—thus changing teachers’ practices and roles. In these debates, losses of autonomy lamented by teachers mirrored what has been called a ‘deprofessionalisation’ of teaching (Barksdale-Ladd and Thomas, 2000; Webb et al., 2004). At the same time, in some countries, such as England, the current rhetoric stresses the government's trust in teachers and talk of ‘professional autonomy’ has come to the forefront (DfE, 2010). In light of this, a more rigorous understanding of the role of autonomy in teaching expertise seems necessary. Definitions of teaching expertise are controversial (Cribb and Gewirtz, 2007; Maxwell, 2015; Winch, 2017). Teaching is a polymorphous ability (Winch, 2017) and while one can broadly assert that it comprises both subject knowledge and practical knowledge of how to present one's subject in a pedagogically effective way, it is very much a matter of dispute whether categories of teachers’ knowledge such as technical knowledge about teaching and learning, as well as practical wisdom (Biesta, 2015), should be included in this conception. More generally, what these forms of knowledge amount to and what their relationships are, is a subject of debate. It remains a question whether they constitute the basis for claiming a specific teaching expertise (Maxwell, 2015). The claim supported by this paper sees our specific understanding of these kinds of knowledge and abilities as fundamentally depending on our understanding of the role of teachers, within an educational system and in relation to educational aims. This, in turn, has consequences for the way in which teaching expertise can be developed and has practical implications, for example, in relation to policy arrangements in teachers’ education.
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2771595879
FWCI: 5.841
Cites: 81
Cited by: 9
Related to: 10