Year: 2020
Type: article
Abstract: The African American daughter of one of us called from New York City in early March, worried about her Hispanic partner's health.Did his high fevers, worsening shortness of breath, and painful cough indicate coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) infection?Given his history of asthma and hypertension, was he at high risk?What should they do?Urged to seek medical attention, he resisted.The nearby affordable and accessible urgent care clinics were staffed by physicians who, based on his previous experiences, "just didn't get it," and he anticipated that his concerns would be dismissed.When he relented and requested a coronavirus test, he was asked about international travel, but not about their small apartment or his use of public transportation.He was told "no test," once again confirming his impressions of an uncaring system.He decided to stay at home and tough it out.But he got worse.The fevers were unrelenting, and it was hard to breathe.He was finally cajoled to try a different clinic.There, the African American receptionist conveyed their concerns and the staff agreed to provide a COVID-19 test.The patient was handed a flyer with home care instructions, but no one asked about financial consequences of staying home and no follow-up plans were provided.And then good news-the clinic called and reported that the test was negative.Yet, a week later, the high fevers continued.They reached out to the clinic again and were reassured that "there [was] nothing to be done for coronavirus."When they asked why the nurse was labeling him a "COVID patient" when his test was negative for coronavirus, the response was an unapologetic "Oops, you got the wrong result."Now a month later, he is still recovering from COVID-19 and from another painful health care encounter.Why are we-a black senior educator, a white medical foundation president, and a Hispanic public health leader-coming together to share this story?This case is a personal illustration of how the long-standing systemic inequalities in the US health care system result in the tragically unequal effect of COVID-19.Many of the contributing factors-from higher rates of underlying disease risk factors, to long-standing lack of access to health care, to lack of cultural competency, to adverse social determinants of health-predict a higher incidence and worse outcomes for minorities.We are deeply disappointed, but not surprised.As of April 7, disturbing national trends are suggested, despite incomplete data capture.In New York, Hispanic and black people accounted for 34% and 28%, respectively, of deaths from COVID-19, even though they represent only 29% and 22% of the population; while white people accounted for 27% of deaths, even though they represent 32% of the population.In Chicago, black people comprise 32% of the
Source: JAMA
Institutions: University of Arizona, Canyon Ranch Institute, Lasker Foundation
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Keywords: health disparities, COVID-19 pandemic, racial and ethnic disparities, Hispanic Americans, African Americans, health care access, cultural competence, social determinants of health, COVID-19 testing, health equity, urgent care centers, patient experience, health workforce diversity, health policy reform
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W3015937556
