A Study of the Effectiveness of Written Corrective Feedback on L2 Development by Japanese Learners of English
Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The purpose of this dissertation is to identify the most effective form of written corrective feedback (CF) for Japanese learners of English according to their English proficiency levels.In order to accomplish the purpose, the relative effectiveness of written CF was examined under some circumstances; the effectiveness of written CF on improvement in text revisions and the writing of new texts, on improvement in different types of tasks, and on development both of explicit and implicit knowledge (Studies 1 -4).Besides, this dissertation examined learners' attitudes toward written CF, which are considered to influence the effect of written CF, in order to consider the relationship between the effectiveness of written CF and learners' affective states to written CF (Study 5).The main findings showed that for higher proficiency learners, any type of written CF had a positive effect on L2 development.However, no predominance of any type of written CF was found.Study 1 investigated the relative effectiveness between direct written CF and metalinguistic written CF on text revisions and on new pieces of writing through three provisions of written CF, and found that written CF positively influenced the text revisions, but no clear difference was found between direct written CF and metalinguistic written CF, and that the effect of written CF on new pieces of writing was not clear.Study 2, which examined the relative effectiveness between focused direct written CF, unfocused direct written CF, and focused metalinguistic written CF, proved that no forms of written CF had any difference on improvement in accuracy examined in three different tests.Study 2 focused on the same grammatical category as Study 1, the conditionals.This is true for the results of Study 4, which examined the relative effectiveness of indirect, direct, and metalinguistic written CF in the long term, treating different grammatical category, present and past perfect tense forms.From these findings, it is possible to say that written CF is actually helpful for higher proficiency leaners in L2 development, however it is unclear as to what the most effective written CF is in this proficiency group.On the other hand, for lower proficiency learners, metalinguistic written CF, which gives learners metalinguistic information about forms and rules, can be most effective in L2 development.xv
Authors: 聡 青山, Satoshi Aoyama
Language: English
Subfield: Language and Linguistics
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3020310845
