Year: 1999
Type: letter
Abstract: The case described by Dr Branthwaite (Anaesthesia 1999; 54: 166–7), which took place in our hospital, raises several important issues, the most important of which is whether the patient gave proper informed consent. Current guidance on obtaining written consent requires that this is obtained by a person with a comprehensive understanding of the procedure or treatment and, in the main, relates to surgical operations [1]. We are unaware of any circumstance in which separate written consent is obtained by an anaesthetist. In most cases consent to anaesthesia is either implied or is obtained verbally. We question whether this practice should be reviewed? In our case, the patient was involved in a demonstration of a new device, the intubating laryngeal mask, prior to the start of a clinical trial. This had been previously approved by the Local Research Ethics Committee (LREC). Ethical Committee approval is not required if patients are being used for demonstration or teaching. We question whether it should be. At present, patients are not informed as to who is going to undertake a particular procedure, nor of the operator's experience, nor who will be present during the procedure. We again question whether they have a right to know. The issues we have raised are not within the remit of the LREC and we are unaware of any hospital in the United Kingdom that has a body which can provide guidance on such matters. As a direct result of this case, we have set up a Trust Ethics Committee to advise on the matters raised. The committee's membership includes clinicians, both medical and nursing, therapists and patient representatives and is chaired by a nonexecutive director of the Trust. Other issues that will be dealt with by the committee will include providing advice to clinicians as to when variation of a standard technique constitutes a new development requiring LREC approval and what information should be given to the patient in such circumstances. These are decisions that are acknowledged as being difficult [2, 3]. We commend our approach to you and, given the need for greater openness, feel that the issues we have raised merit wider debate.
Source: Anaesthesia
Author: D. J. Scott
Institution: Conquest Hospital
Language: English
Topic: Ethics in Clinical Research
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W3026091351
