Year: 2020
Type: conference-paper
Study design: Clinical Trial
Abstract: To support human decision making with machine learning models, we often need to elucidate patterns embedded in the models that are unsalient, unknown, or counterintuitive to humans. While existing approaches focus on explaining machine predictions with real-time assistance, we explore model-driven tutorials to help humans understand these patterns in a train- ing phase. We consider both tutorials with guidelines from scientific papers, analogous to current practices of science communication, and automatically selected examples from training data with explanations. We use deceptive review detection as a testbed and conduct large-scale, randomized human-subject experiments to examine the effectiveness of such tutorials. We find that tutorials indeed improve human performance, with and without real-time assistance. In particular, although deep learning provides superior predictive performance than simple models, tutorials and explanations from simple models are more useful to humans. Our work suggests future directions for human-centered tutorials and explanations towards a synergy between humans and AI.
Authors: Vivian Lai, Han Liu, Chenhao Tan
Institution: University of Colorado Boulder
Language: English
Subfield: Artificial Intelligence
Field: Computer Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
Awards: CRII: CHS: Harnessing Machine Learning to Improve Human Decision Making: A Case Study on Deceptive Detection, AI-DCL: EAGER: Explanations through Diverse, Feasible, and Interactive Counterfactuals, BIGDATA: IA: Automating Analysis and Feedback to Improve Mathematics Teachers' Classroom Discourse, G5923554081
OpenAlex ID: W3032816739
