Assessing the Decision-Making Process for Choosing Software Development Contracts: Implications and Improvements
Year: 2018
Type: dissertation
Abstract: BackgroundThere is a need to gain an increased understanding of the factors that affect the decisionmaking process for choosing software contract types.Initially, the thesis set out to identify the underlying reasons for why customers tend to favour fixed-price, fixed-scope contracts.However, looking further into this matter it became natural to expand the research focus.Instead of solely addressing the reasons for why fixed-price, fixed-scope contracts remain popular -despite the increasing popularity of agile methodologies -the actual implications of contract type choices proved more interesting. AimThe aim (and structure) of this thesis is two-pronged, mainly as a result of the readjusted focus as described above.Going from a somewhat narrow problem formulation (i.e. the why's for choosing fixed-price, fixed-scope contracts), to a more general one (i.e. the why's for choosing any contract type), gives rise to two clear areas of focus.Namely understanding and improving the decision-making process for choosing software contract types.Firstly, the thesis sets out to identify the various factors that affect the choice of contract type, as well as the implications of making inadequate choices.Secondly, the thesis advocates for a thorough application of complexity analysis of the envisioned software product as a basis for deciding on a specific contract type.Arguably this will improve the overall decision-making process by increasing the likelihood of contract and process suitability with regards to the product. MethodFor the purpose of answering the research questions formulated in this thesis (presented in Chapter 1 Introduction), the initial research was conducted through a qualitative case study.The case study looked into the context of a large Norwegian software provider and an ongoing project conducted for the governmental sector.The data collected initially came from observations and interviews.However, as research progressed, it became natural to conduct an additional literature review of existing research publications.This proved highly valuable for gaining further insights on the readjusted scope.Data analysis was conducted using principles from Grounded Theory, such as the application of coding. V ResultsThe preliminary analysis identified several reasons for why customers tend to favour fixedprice, fixed-scope contracts.However, the main reason was very clearly attributed to the lack of trust between parties.Arguably, since customers were found to not fully trust the provider, opting for a plan-driven contract was their way of attempting to gain control over the development process.Simultaneously however, software providers have become prominent advocates for agile software development.As a consequence, the process for choosing a software contract type may be inadequate, and ultimately complicates the development process. ConclusionThe choice of software development contract type is often rooted in process-aspects, rather than product-aspects.In essence, the customer's desire to define the ways in which to work (process) outweighs the desire to define the software to be developed (product).This is unfortunate, as scholars stress that the nature of the product hugely affects the efficiency and suitability of the chosen development process.By implication, the complexity of the product should undeniably affect the choice of contract type.Therefore, the suggestion is to consider complexity theory and analysis, particularly the Cynefin framework, in relation to the envisioned software product prior to deciding on a specific contract type.
Source: NVA (Nasjonalt vitenarkiv)
Author: Yulai de Meer Fjeld
Institution: University of Oslo
Language: English
Subfield: Information Systems
Field: Computer Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3033677328
