Work

Introduction: Featured Collection on Transboundary Aquifers

Year: 2020
Type: article
Abstract: Groundwater is the most extracted natural resource in the planet and it provides around 45% of human freshwater needs (Eckstein 2017). Yet, the understanding and comprehension of our dependence on groundwater and its interactions with natural and human systems, is as limited and superficial as the existent — or nonexistent — regulatory and management systems in place. More than a decade ago, the World Bank estimated that all easily available surface water and exclusively national sources of water (groundwater) have already been developed or are in the process of development (Varis et al. 2008). Consequently, approximately 40% of the world’s population rely on transboundary river/aquifer basins to supply their water needs (Eckstein 2017). As competition for fresh water increases, border communities around the world are facing growth in the dependence, reliance, risk, conflict, and cooperation with their neighbors. Water security is not a new challenge for these regions; however, resilience and sustainability risks coupled with water scarcity, climate change, environmental degradation, and population growth have placed additional pressure on the level of threats to water security in border regions around the world. The strategic and geopolitical value of groundwater resources located across political boundaries, as well as the physical complexity intrinsically attached to transboundary groundwater systems, encompasses critical considerations at the technical and institutional level. Border communities that depend on shared water resources around the world face the highest threat in terms of water security given deficiencies on the policy development for the management of shared water resources, especially groundwater (Varis et al. 2008). Currently, groundwater governance regimes seem to be limited or at the very least, not prepared to address the transboundary nature or the transboundariness, of a growing dependable resource traditionally assumed to have a never-ending supply. Water resources in the border region between Mexico and the United States (U.S.) have historically been a matter of national security. In a region with around 15 million inhabitants, the risks associated with shared surface and groundwater resources, have escalated over the last decades as water scarcity, extreme drought and flood events, and population growth have put serious pressure on the availability of water resources and therefore the resilience of border communities. Public health threats associated with degrading water quality, lack of research and data on current groundwater conditions, limited binational efforts on holistic basin water management, and unsustainable growing population centers highly dependent on groundwater resources, are some of the most pressing water security threats in the region (Sanchez et al. 2016). Additionally, the vulnerability of border communities, particularly toward the easternmost part of the border, is exacerbated by the less than state average standards in education, public health, poverty, security, and income per capita (US Census Bureau 2018). Water security in the border region as well as water policy development becomes then a multidimensional, transboundary challenge as environmental, socioeconomic, and hydrogeological conditions tend to be more related and responsive to a transboundary regional logic than to a national jurisdiction or national policy. In the border region between the U.S. and Texas, particularly in the Middle Rio Grande (from El Paso to Del Rio), groundwater is the major source of water for domestic and agriculture use. Contrastingly, in the Lower Rio Grande (from Del Rio to Brownsville), surface water becomes the main source of water for agriculture, and groundwater remains the primary source for domestic and potable use for urban centers. Because surface sources of water (Rio Grande River) are fully allocated and drought conditions are becoming the norm throughout the region, groundwater has become the alternative new source of water, though extraction and treatment costs are highly variable across the basin. In the border region between New Mexico, Arizona, and Mexico, groundwater dependency for border communities and economic development is even more critical. For example, groundwater supply for all types of uses for border communities that overlay the aquifer basins of the Mimbres in New Mexico, and Santa Cruz and San Pedro in Arizona, can be close to 90%. In the case of California, groundwater dependency for the Mexicali Valley is a well-known study case that has proven the sensitive connectivity of the Colorado River to the regional transboundary aquifers, and therefore water intensive agriculture and protected areas that require minimum base flow for its sustainability, have been historically important drivers of binational negotiations over shared water resources. Currently, there is limited and in some cases, nonexistent reliable information regarding the location, boundaries, and condition of transboundary aquifer systems between Mexico and the U.S. Current research suggests there could be up to 36 transboundary aquifers located at the border between Mexico and the U.S. (Sanchez et al. 2016). However, studies that are more recent have proven that between Mexico and Texas only, there may be at least 25 transboundary aquifers (Sanchez et al. 2018). These findings demonstrate that the number of purely physical unknowns supersede by far what the current research has been able to accomplish. Aside from the undisputable need for more research and funding to address the data lacking on the physical conditions of the groundwater systems that traverse political borders, the key challenge stems from the reliance on antiquated and poorly developed institutional and regulatory frameworks that do not acknowledge the shared nature of groundwater resources in their policies and management practices. The power of the unseen, uncertainty of the models, limited regulation, disagreement on criteria and methods of boundary delineation, as well as limited data, and sharing mechanisms (mostly at international level), irremediably generates a negligent environment toward the sustainability of transboundary aquifers. This feature collection attempts to paint a portrait of some challenges that particular regions within the U.S. and across its southern border with Mexico are currently facing as transboundary aquifer systems transform jurisdictions into virtual barriers that are urging institutions and legal regimes to respond to pressing conditions and potential vulnerabilities of shared groundwater systems. Additionally, this edition attempts to offer a variety of options, recommendations, and perspectives to understand, and address transboundary water issues under the current legal constraints and looking toward potential adaptation to worsening water conditions in those regions highly dependent on groundwater for economic and population growth. Contributing authors provide interesting legal and institutional assessments both at domestic and international level, to highlight innovative modeling and technical capabilities, as well as new approaches to address the challenges that this research area has just begun to call the attention of researchers and authorities at domestic and international level. The analyses provided do not pretend to propose an exhaustive number of study cases nor its complete implications. The reality of challenges that remain to be addressed, understand, and even discover in the groundwater flow systems across political boundaries, extend beyond our scientific endeavors, but papers in this collection do provide important guidelines, technical simulations, and experiences worth sharing that might be applicable to other regions of the world. In addition, our objective is to contribute to the growing empirical literature of the topic in much need of development. We believe that the studies presented here provide a good starting point to understand the multiple dimensions and complex nature of transboundary aquifers along the U.S.–Mexico border that will help fuel future research and inform policy dialog across management institutions in both countries that share this hidden yet valuable resource. Rosario Sanchez involved in conceptualization, methodology, and writing — original draft of this paper. John Tracy involved in project administration, supervision, and writing — review and editing of this paper.
Language: English
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W3035738372
FWCI:
Cites: 4
Cited by:
Related to: 9