Children's Rights, Educational Research and the UNCRC: Past, Present and FutureJennaGillet‐Swan and VickiCoppock (Eds) Oxford: Symposium Books, 2016. ISBN 978‐1‐873927‐95‐3, Cost £36.00. 166 pp
Year: 2020
Type: book-review
Abstract: ‘Children's Rights, Educational Research and the UNCRC: Past, Present and Future’ represents an amalgamation of ideas generated at the 2014 European Conference of Education Research. This comprehensive international anthology examines, as the title suggests, how ideas originating from the UNCRC influence, inform or underpin the work being conducted in the contemporary classroom from the perspectives of the teachers, learners and researchers. The volume is divided into seven chapters whose distinctly international contributors affords the collection a richly diverse quality that draws on multiple perspectives. Predicated on the basis that UNCRC-focussed teaching practice is important and significant, this volume offers a relevant and practical lens for critical discussion around the implementation of such practice. Whilst rooted in education, its key UNCRC-focussed message is likely to stimulate thought and discussion for those working within other modern day institutions in terms of their responsibilities and opportunities for practice. In chapter 1, John I'Anson introduces the reader to the way in which UNCRC themes and ‘orienting tropes’ (voice, participation and ecological perspectives) overlap across the different fields of children's rights, politics and policy, and in so doing, take on different orientations, which could potentially extend the ways children's rights in education can be researched. He discusses whether broader approaches (via international comparisons, rights extension and theory proliferation) might present further research opportunities to anchor and solidify a UNCRC ethos before moving on to scrutinise the prevailing tensions that require some unravelling to achieve this (advocacy and criticality, accountability agendas and the impact of different research ontologies). He ends the chapter by focussing on how interconnecting theories might offer a solution to flatten out these tensions and thus facilitate research progress. The focus of chapter 2, authored by Louise Phillips, is to remind us of the duties of all member States, as enshrined in Article 42, to disseminate ‘to adults and children alike’, ‘the principles and provisions of the Convention’ and to do so ‘by appropriate and active means’. Yet, as this author highlights, the message of children as ‘rights bearers’ has become stifled not only by the ways in which the notion of ‘childhood’ has been historically constructed and depicted but by how hegemonic polices and legislation continue to proliferate ideas that relegate children to a ‘caretaker status’ and restrict a child's status of rights holder. Whilst acknowledging the attempts (by mostly NGOs) to reach public awareness, she suggests the significant dissemination needed will only occur alongside shifts in attitudes where children's rights are both prioritised and disseminated on their own media platforms. Nina Thelander turns attention in chapter 3 to the teaching of human rights, specifically of children's human rights, in Sweden. She uses data from a larger case study to micro-investigate how and what it is teachers are actually prioritising in their civics syllabus for years 4–6 in relation to (children's) human rights. This study focusses on the analysis of the narratives employed by two teachers in relation to three different aspects of human rights education relevant to Sweden: ‘knowledge and skills’, ‘values, attitudes and behaviour’ and ‘actions to promote, protect or defend human rights’. What she demonstrates is how contemporary national thinking about human rights is affected by and connected to global and historical ideas, thus acknowledging the importance of reflecting the spatial and temporal reach and practice of children's rights in the national syllabus. In chapter 4, we discover how the tenets of Article 12, as enshrined in legislation in the context of Finnish education, are influencing the ability of children there to express their views and participate in decisions that affect their learning lives. Teetta Niemi, Kristiina Kumpulainen and Lasse Lipponen investigate this issue in their longitudinal action research project with a class of primary school students. A useful summary of prevailing concepts and models associated generally with the concept of participation is offered, before it is embedded within the national educational context. What follows is an informative description of how children are engaged to provide visual and verbal feedback, usually through different forms of ranking processes, about classroom practice and initiatives. Whilst recognising the limitations posed by policy, other forms of child-facilitated participation available across school life are also considered. Contemporary Portugese life forms the backdrop to chapter 5. The authors, Joana Lucio and Fernando Ilidio Ferreira look at how State imposed economic austerity measures detrimentally affect children's access to citizenship and political engagement; where at a time of scarce resources, public social investment is not being directed to children's rights education but elsewhere. Consequently, the authors paint a bleak picture of how it is student teachers feel constrained to impart their theoretical knowledge to support instances where children could benefit from a rights-focussed stance. Gordon Tait and Mallihai Tambyah tackle the ramifications of Article 16 in chapter 6 to expose how very wide ranging ‘natural’ privacies afforded a child do not translate into practice. They suggest that in fact, the life of the Australian child has never been more public which they achieve through an exploration of both historical and contemporary perspectives, and by focussing on ideas associated with ‘childhood as a regulated space’, in both private (family) and public (education) spheres. They finish by considering future problematics associated with ‘privacy’, in terms of tensions between individual and State, the complexity in defining ‘privacy’ and the worthlessness of a right that has no legal redress. The volume closes with a more optimistic turn to future horizons of children's rights based educational research, which provides the editors with space to highlight opportunities for researchers to respond to and connect with the ways today's children engage with the world. Ultimately, it is envisaged that a digitally and otherwise technologically focussed platform will also enable children to connect themselves to expanding knowledge around their UNCRC rights and thereby involve them in their own rights-based learning experience.
Source: Children & Society
DOI: 10.1111/chso.12405
Author: Sara L. Hammond
Institution: The Open University
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W3036091022
