Good Guys and Bad Guys: Punishing Character, Equality and the Irrelevance of Moral Character to Criminal Punishment
Year: 2004
Type: article
Abstract: GOOD GUYS AND BAD GUYS 1021punishing offenders because they are bad people^ is unjust in the same way that that the Arab-American driver on the street was treated unjustly.He fit the profile of the bad guy and suffered as a result.This article reflects the danger of premising our justification of punishment on another's character.The end of my reflections will be to rediscover and demonstrate the critical importance of the act requirement in the criminal law.^I conclude with a plea to treat the criteria of criminalThe image of bad guys also creates a distinction between criminals and other members of society.Many see criminals as possessing the sum of all the moral faults we condemn.The offender represents all our immoral temptations.Conceiving the criminal as an immoral other erects a complete separation, erasing the notion of the offender's common humanity.Absent this image of common humanity, punishment is freed of any constraints.Measuring criminal punishment by immoral character does more than segregate the offender.Character judgments tum this separation from society into a permanent banishment.Judgments about the criminal become fixed, an image of permanent immoral character.This image of immoral character is first found in Aristotle.Today's penal practices manifest this view of permanent immoral character defects in criminal offenders.Such practices include punishment regimes like "Three Strikes and Out," permanent disenfranchisement and other collateral punishments.The drive to punish for character means the law must find a way of assessing character.In order to unearth a criminal offender's character, philosophers and theorists link criminal acts to underlying bad character.Early examples are found in the work of David Hume.Modem
Source: Cardozo law review
Author: Ekow N. Yankah
Language: English
Topic: Criminal Law and Policy
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3041069491
