Work

Higher technical education consultation : analysis : Research report, July 2020

Year: 2020
Type: other
Abstract: Uploading data sets to NVivo 12 Plus software for detailed qualitative data analysis. 6.All coded data was analysed for each theme to identify recurring issues, where there were multiple references, areas of consensus, and other feedback.Quotes from responses are used to illustrate themes and key points throughout.The themes were reviewed in line with sub-groups to identify any differences among respondent groups. Key findings7.There were 155 responses to the consultation comprising 132 online responses and 23 email responses.The respondent group was made up of seven different sub-groups.The largest group was professional/business organisations, followed by higher education (HE) providers and further education (FE) providers. Higher technical qualifications (HTQs)8.There was strong agreement with the proposed aims of HTQs as laid out in the consultation document and widespread support for the ambition that they provide a highquality technical route for young people and adults and deliver much-needed skills for current and future labour markets. 9.Key to the success of HTQs was believed to be strong, well-functioning and long-term partnerships between industry and academia, and sustained government support in raising their profile and prestige amongst students and employers. 10.Respondents were seeking a well-defined, fair, transparent and efficient approval process.They wanted this to be in-line with existing systems and able to respond to the everchanging needs of the market. 11.They wanted relevant stakeholders to be involved and consulted in the approval process from the start to ensure assessment frameworks are fit-for-purpose and consistent workable practices are embedded. 12.It was felt that panels and groups in the approvals process should not be limited to a small number of influential stakeholders.Instead they should have diverse, representative expertise, capturing a wide-range of industrial and pedagogical perspectives.This would enable them to recognise effective learning models, as well as industry best practice.13.Where supported, mapping qualifications against occupational standards was thought to be valuable in ensuring consistent delivery and providing clear entry routes into skilled employment.However, it was felt that the design of standards needed to be carefully considered to avoid risking gaps in provision, narrowing skill sets and to ensure that the breadth of technical and creative sector demands are met.Clear, up-to-date and flexible standards and definitions were considered imperative to ensuring that provision not only meets 20.HTE was thought to have a key role to play in promoting social mobility, particularly for those in low-skilled work and in jobs at risk of obsolesce (due to technological advances).For HTE to fulfil this role would, however, require sometimes entrenched perceptions that technical education is a second choice to academic university routes to be challenged. 21.Respondents highlighted the importance of investing in raising awareness of HTE.This could take the form of active promotion, campaigns and close collaborative working with professional bodies and employers.In addition, it was felt that investment and training were also essential in ensuring that careers IAG is of a high standard and can provide information on clear and coherent career pathways for a wide range of HTE learners. 22.It was argued that careers IAG for technical education should start at a younger age, be accessible to learners already in employment, and specifically target teachers and parents as important influencers.Provision of IAG should utilise multiple communication channels including social media, employer events and online learning options. 23.Employers and professional bodies were thought to have a key role to play in this through work placements, case study development and the provision of talks or presentations.Building links and creating partnerships with business organisations/professional bodies was felt to be important in supporting their involvement in the provision of IAG, improving the response to skills shortages and ensuring full employer involvement in course development. 24.Some respondents also commented on the need to give specific consideration to the information and access needs of specific groups, including those with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND), adult learners and other minority groups. Wider impact 25.There was significant discussion of the barriers faced by different groups in accessing HTE.Respondents wanted a HTE system that successfully overcomes major barriers by ensuring that HTQs have credibility and by providing sufficient funding, targeted support, work environment adjustments, and learning delivery options e.g.virtual learning.In this respect, ensuring that HTQs work effectively for adult learners looking to re-train and switch careers was felt to be crucial. 26.Although support for the consultation proposals was widely expressed, there were some concerns that respondents felt should be given further consideration.Key issues for further consideration were: the fit of HTQs within the complex technical education and HE landscape; fit with the recommendations emerging from the Augar Report; and, an avoidance of greater complexity and bureaucracy.1 Department for Education (July, 2019) Higher technical education: the current system and the case for change.2 Department for Education (July, 2019) Higher technical education: the current system and the case for change.13 during the review, DfE launched its proposals for consultation on 8 July 2019, alongside a case for change document and its interim impact assessments. 32.The key proposals for consultation were 3 :• Prestigious qualifications that are recognised nationally as providing the skills that employers want.DfE proposed an opt-in, national system where qualifications at this level can be recognised and signalled as providing the knowledge, skills, and behaviours set out in occupational standards, so that students and employers can have confidence in them.DfE proposed that this be delivered through a straightforward and streamlined approvals process led by the Institute for Apprenticeships and Technical Education (the Institute), working with employers through its Route Panels.DfE also proposed strong incentives for Awarding Bodies to submit qualifications for approval and maintaining the wider regulation of Awarding Bodies through the existing systems provided by Ofqual and Office for Students (OfS).• More high-quality courses delivered in FE and HE providers, including National Colleges and Institutes of Technology.DfE proposed developing, with the OfS, a set of technical ongoing registration conditions to enable providers delivering courses leading to Institute-approved HTQs to demonstrate and improve the quality of their technical provision.DfE also proposed linking student and provider funding for HTQs to those conditions.• That HTE becomes a positive and popular choice both for younger students and for those upskilling and retraining while in the workforce.DfE proposed measures to increase the awareness, prestige and recognition of HTE, as well as the information, advice and guidance available to potential students of all ages and employers.DfE also proposed improving the accessibility of HTE through flexible delivery and improved signposting of financial support, and ensuring that students have the ongoing personal support to continue and complete their course of study.33.These proposals form one part of DfE's wider programme of reforms to strengthen and grow technical education, including the roll-out of T Levels, the National Retraining Scheme and investments in apprenticeships, Institutes of Technology and National Colleges.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
Funder: Strong
OpenAlex ID: W3044084463
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10