Work

The Impact of Competition on Cooperation: Evidence from a Series of Bargaining Game Experiments

Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Rationality has long been one of the key principles of economics because it seeks to explain patterns of behavior and preferences in economic interactions.The belief that economic agents interact to maximize individual gain as a means of making themselves better off helps to explain the motivations underlying exchange as a fundamental concept of economics.Specific to game theory, theories of rationality predict that individuals are so-called "rational" agents who behave in such a way as to maximize individual gain in social dilemmas even at the expense of others.However, both laboratory experiments and everyday behavior challenge these existing theories by demonstrating that humans do in fact cooperate in competitive social situations at a cost to themselves.These findings call into question the theoretical framework of rationality foundational to game theory and suggest the presence of external factors that may influence our willingness to cooperate in competitive environments.The goal of this research is to analyze the impact of three of these potential factorsintensity of competition, game duration, and group size-on cooperation through a series of bargaining game experiments.Analysis of earnings and claims across several iterations of a Traveler's Dilemma bargaining game allowed for conclusions to be drawn about the relationship between these factors and cooperation.Our results show this relationship to be significant in the cases of game duration and group size, but insignificant for intensity of competition.Of notable importance is the clear impact of increasing group size in our experiments as a model of the Tragedy of the Commons theory of shared resources.Our results offer strong support for the Tragedy of the Commons in that they reflect a significant decrease in earnings and claims as group size increased.These results are consistent with the predictions of the Tragedy of the
Author: C. S. Wright
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3045048921
Cites: 25
Cited by:
Related to: 10