Ethics in nursing management: Identifying ethical problems and methods used by nurse managers to solve these
Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: ABSTRACT Nurse managers (NMs) have a significant role clarifying the vision, mission and values of their organization to nursing staff. They influence nursing practice so that high ethical standards are maintained and the dignity of patients is respected. In this study, NMs’ work was studied from the viewpoint of ethical problems. The first aim of this study was to investigate the ethical problems in NMs’ work - the nature, frequency and difficulty of the problems. The second aim was to investigate the frequency of use and usefulness of the methods used in solving ethical problems in NMs’ work. Finally, the third aim was to determine the background factors associated with encountering ethical problems and theirsolving. This study was carried out in three phases. In the first phase, a cross-sectional survey was conducted to investigate the frequency of ethical problems (16 items) in NMs’ work and explore the role of codes of ethics in solving them, and determine the background factors associated with ethical problems and the use of codes of ethics. The sample of this phase consisted of NMs (N = 501, n= 205, response rate 41%) working in strategic, middle and ward management in 21 healthcare organizations in 2 hospital districts in Finland. The second phase, where the aim was to identify and describe ethical problems in NMs’ work, was carried out using 9 semi-structured interviews with NMs in strategic, middle and ward management. The third phase consisted of a nationwide cross-sectional survey (N = 1,086, n = 214, response rate 20%) among NMs in strategic, middle and ward management in 4 out of ten largest cities and 5 hospital districts in Finland, members of a register for academic nurse managers, and participants of an education meeting targeted at NMs. The survey focused on investigating the frequency and difficulty of ethical problems (65 items) and the frequency of use and usefulness of their solving methods (40 items) in NMs’ work and the associated background factors. In phases I and III, the data were analysed statistically and in phase II, with content analysis. The results showed that NMs encounter a variety of different ethical problems in their work. Over half of the NMs encountered ethical problems at least weekly. The most often encountered and most difficult ethical problems were related to organizations. Discussion and deliberation, including discussions with different stakeholders and personal values, were the most often used methods in solving ethical problems. Most of the methods were considered useful, but most of them were rarely used by the majority of the NMs. There were work-related background factors that associated with ethical problems so that the more positively NMs perceived their work, the less frequently they encountered ethical problems and the easier they considered them. Nurse managers need to advance discussion of ethical problems in healthcare organizations and act to strengthen resources for ethics, such as ethics experts, ethics committees and instructions for repeated situations involving ethical problems. The results of this study may also be used in education for nursing management. Further studies are needed to investigate especially the most frequent and most difficult ethical problems with different methods, like observations or interventions, to find out how they may be reduced and solved effectively. KEYWORDS: nursing management, nurse manager, ethics, ethical problems, solving methods
Source: UTUPub (University of Turku)
Author: Elina Aitamaa
Language: English
Topic: Ethics in medical practice
Subfield: General Health Professions
Field: Health Professions
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3047384332
