Work

How to stop the errors and retain the real: Researchers need transparency, better indexing, and a willingness to look again at the paper they intend to cite

Year: 2020
Type: report
Abstract: Papers are cited for years after they are retracted, usually without any indication that they are no longer officially part of the scientific literature. Many people citing these works likely do not know about the retractions: once a citation is recorded in researchers’ reference-tracking software, they may never look at it again. Journals and indices need to do a better job of flagging papers that have been retracted or corrected, and abstracts, indexing and related surveys need to do a better job propagating that information. Once a researcher does find a flag, it is not always clear what to do. One potential solution is for journals to include a recommendation within a retraction notice about whether and how it should be cited. The ideal solution is to provide a much transparency around a retraction as possible, including the cause, whether there is consensus between authors and between authors and editors, who initiated the retraction, and the role of any post-publication review. Of course, the value of such transparency still depends on researchers’ ability to find retraction notices and their willingness to read them.
Author: Monya Baker
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3091284720
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10