Work

Canadian-borns' Biases towards Immigrants - an Intersectional Perspective: A focus on Ethnicity, Gender, and Sexual Orientation in Exploring Intergroup Bias

Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Most research on bias towards immigrants has engaged itself with the generic immigrant, seemingly lacking ethnicity, gender, and/or sexual orientation. In addition, previous research indicates that most bias research is based on prototypical (i.e., usually the heterosexual male) members of marginalized groups. Furthermore, much of the research has examined biases per uni-dimensional measures, focusing on the amount of negative bias, rarely highlighting different types of biases. This exploratory research examines the qualitatively different types of univalent and ambivalent biases immigrants of intersectional social locations are likely to receive as they enter and settle in Canada. Biases towards heterosexual, gay and lesbian immigrant men and women from four top source nations to Canada (i.e. Britain, China, Iran, Nigeria) are investigated per two exploratory studies. Stereotypes, affective prejudices, and discriminatory tendencies directed at 16 immigrant subgroups are measured using a bi-dimensional framework- the Stereotype Content Model (SCM) and Behaviors from Intergroup Affect and Stereotypes (BIAS) map. Study 1 is a preliminary exploration, utilizing methodology and scales traditionally used by SCM and BIAS map research by asking a sample of 232 second- and third-generation Canadians to report what biases they believe exist for the immigrant subgroups in Canada. Study 2 extends these findings by exploring 1,105 participants’ own biases towards the immigrants, incorporating SCM and BIAS map within a contextualized vignette design with concretized discriminatory behaviour items pertaining to areas relevant to newcomers’ entry and settlement. While participants anticipated bias patterns for immigrants that would produce clustering mostly by ethnicity (Study 1), patterns based on participants’ own biases (Study 2) showed more substantial interplay of all three group memberships. Exploratory analyses in both studies reveal prototypical immigrants adhered more to the predicted bias patterns than non-prototypical immigrants who received more ambivalent and, at times, conflicting, bias patterns. Results show the importance of intersectional and multidimensional frameworks for intergroup bias research. Theoretical and practical implications are discussed with the hope that future research will utilize these results to extend our knowledge in the area and, thus, contribute to the cultivation of more equal spaces and opportunities for the diverse pool of immigrants Canada receives.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3096132904
Cites: 263
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10