Year: 2017
Type: dissertation
Study design: Clinical Trial
Abstract: Acute abdominal pain (AAP) is a common cause for emergency department (ED) visits in patients of all ages.There are numerous potential underlying causes of AAP, ranging from self-limiting conditions to life-threatening emergencies.The clinical diagnosis is often difficult because similar symptoms may be encountered in many diseases.Nonetheless, delayed diagnosis is associated with adverse outcomes and therefore, timely and accurate identification of the underlying cause is necessary for ensuring appropriate patient management.Elderly AAP patients often have atypical clinical presentations, making the diagnosis particularly challenging.The spectrum and distribution of diagnoses also differ from those present in younger age groups; e.g.acute mesenteric ischemia (AMI) mainly affects elderly patients.This is a life-threatening disease demanding prompt diagnosis and treatment, yet difficult to diagnose because of the non-specific symptoms and findings.Due to its high diagnostic accuracy in AAP, computed tomography (CT) has become an important component in diagnosis and guiding patient management.Consequently, CT utilization has increased significantly.However, CT has its disadvantages, one of the most important being the increased cancer risk associated with exposure to ionizing radiation.The economic impact of routine or liberal CT utilization in the whole spectrum of AAP is unclear; this aspect has mainly been studied for suspected appendicitis with diverse results.The aim of this thesis was to evaluate the impact of CT imaging on the diagnosis, patient management and costs of AAP.The first three studies were based on a prospective, randomized trial comparing routine and selective CT use in adult AAP patients admitted to the ED of Kuopio University Hospital from January 2009 to May 2010.The fourth study was a retrospective evaluation conducted on 95 AMI patients who had undergone CT and were treated in Kuopio University Hospital between 2009 and 2013.Altogether 254 patients were analyzed in the first two studies.Routine CT utilization was found to result in higher treatment costs of AAP compared to its selective use, regardless of patient age.The main factor contributing to the higher costs was the longer hospital length of stay (LOS) in the routine CT group.An increase in treatment costs and LOS was observed in conjunction with aging in both study groups.Generally, a tendency towards more specific diagnoses was observed with routine CT compared to selective imaging regardless of patient age.Elderly (> 65 years) patients received a specific diagnosis more often than younger patients in both study groups.In the third study which analyzed 93 patients, the routine use of CT use was found to alter the surgeon's initial assessment of patient management more often than selective CT imaging; routine CT was found to be the only independent parameter predictive of changing the assessment of the need for operative treatment.Additionally, routine CT resulted in higher diagnostic accuracy and was found to increase diagnostic confidence.In the fourth study, ED radiologists were observed to make a correct diagnosis of AMI in the CT studies of AAP significantly more often when AMI was suspected prior to CT compared to the opposite situation.AMI was suspected prior to CT in only 31 % of the patients, and therefore, most CT studies were not being performed with imaging protocols that are regarded as optimal VI for AMI.Nevertheless, CT protocols played only a minor role on the radiologists' abilities to make the correct diagnosis.
Author: Tiina-Talvikki Lehtimäki
Institution: University of Eastern Finland
Language: English
Subfield: Emergency Medicine
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Keywords: acute abdominal pain, computed tomography, acute mesenteric ischemia, emergency department, diagnostic accuracy, length of hospital stay, health care costs, ionizing radiation risk, elderly patients, appendicitis, diagnostic yield, cost-effectiveness, atypical presentation, cost-benefit analysis
Open Access status: green
Funder: Kuopion Yliopistollinen Sairaala
OpenAlex ID: W3096538815
