Esimiehen muuttuvat identiteetit : narratiivinen tutkimus keskijohdon identiteeteistä ja samastumisesta organisaatiomurroksessa
Year: 2014
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This study is looking into the construction of identity and identification of the middle management of one company during personal coaching discussions.The coaching was organized to support the transition phase and management development activities in the organization.The purpose of the study was to widen and deepen understanding with regards to identities both as individually experienced and narrated phenomena.A narrative perspective and method were applied when searching for answers to the two main research questions: Firstly, what forms of identifications are manifested in the personal coaching discussions?Secondly, how does the middle management express their identities, their identity work as well as their identification in the transition phase of the organization?The main assumption was that the nature of the identity can be narrated, socially constructed and it can entail discourse of self.The target group of this research was the entire middle management of the target organization.This consists of 15 managers, with whom 48 personal coaching discussions were held and videotaped.The core of the empirical data are the coaching discussions, the digital records of the discussions as well as 15 word for word transcriptions of them.The study is closely related to the tradition of social constructionism.The empirical analysis of the paper draws influences from the narrative identity research and models regarding identification, that form the basis for the current analysis of the narratives concerning the construction of individual identities and forms of identification.The results of this study indicate that different forms of identification (positive, neutral, ambivalent identification and dis-identification) can be recognized and analyzed within the framework of an empirical data.In addition to a cognitive dimension, there are also emotional and value related aspects in the identification process.A positive identification from the viewpoint of the organization signals stability and management by positive reinforcement among other things.Neutral identification can be observed as a diverse phenomenon: it can transform and change objects relatively quickly, even though it is often described as a stable psychological state.An ambivalent identification can imply overstraining; despite the already existing hard pressure, the manager is forced to use his/her mental capacity to identity work.Evaluation of functional consequences of ambivalent identification on the basis of the corpus of this current research is problematic.It is feasible, however, that an individual with an ambivalent identification will detach him/herself from the organization or will assume a cynical stand unless the ambivalent situation is resolved.It can be evaluated, however, that the individual with ambivalent identification is likely to lose his/her functionality, work related innovativeness and creativity when overstrained, which can have more far reaching consequences to the organization.Dis-identification can also signal functional detachment from the organization -mental detachment has already likely occurred.The results of this research support the views that emphasize the critical and cynical nature of dis-identification.
Author: Pauli T. Kallio
Institution: University of Eastern Finland
Language: Finnish
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: middle managers, organizational identity, identification, disidentification, identity work, organizational change, personal coaching, narrative identity, social constructionism, overstrain, cynicism, management development, creativity, organizational culture, organizational mission statements
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3096703097
