Work

Flipping the Paradigm: The Conceptualization and Practice of Mental Healthcare in Ontario Prisons

Year: 2020
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This dissertation focuses on understandings of mental illness and on the organization and delivery of mental healthcare in Ontario prisons. In the process, I identify a nascent model of correctional medicine in Ontario prisons. Having interviewed both medical professionals and correctional personnel, I give a voice to those who deliver care in prisons in Ontario, a voice that has been rarely heard. Although my focus is on the provision of mental healthcare, the study offers a window into the workings of provincial prisons more generally. Multiple reports, commissions, and ombudspersons have called for improvements to mental healthcare for people in custody. Missing in these discussions is clarity about who and what is being talked about. I start to answer these questions and describe what care is being provided and for whom. I also show that the current practices define people out of the category of mentally ill rather than in. ‘Defining out’ perpetuates the inadequacy of care. Moreover, the inherent subjectivity of mental health diagnoses and treatment is not being mediated by appropriate communication among those delivering care in prisons. I discuss how prisons are becoming de facto mental health facilities; how institutional responses vary across the province of Ontario; and how everyone dealing with mentally ill individuals has to improvise – sometimes just to get everyone through the day as safely as possible. My findings indicate that correctional officers operate with insufficient understandings of mental illness to effectively carry out their current roles as central gatekeepers to mental healthcare. As a result, medical professionals have limited access to the people who would benefit from that expertise. I show how practitioners perceive the patterns of mental healthcare delivery in correctional settings and expose an emerging model of medicine that is distinct from both community medicine and forensic medicine. Throughout the dissertation, I argue for the need to flip the paradigm of mental healthcare from one with a singular focus on illness to one that focuses on wellness in order to better address the mental health needs of all people in prison, including those experiencing forms of ‘un-wellness’.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3097612446
Cites: 127
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10